" /> Wampum: November 2008 Archives

« October 2008 | Main | December 2008 »

November 30, 2008

The BJP wants war

via the Hindu

BJP general secretary Gopinath Munde today said that his party would not allow any official of the Pakistan's Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) agency to "step into Mumbai".

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had earlier asked the Pakistani authorities to send the ISI chief to India to aid the probe of Mumbai terror attacks.

"We do not agree to ISI chief or any other official of that agency coming to India for probe. We will not let anybody from ISI to step into Mumbai," the BJP leader said in a statement.

The statement said that ISI had hand not only in the 1993 Mumbai blasts but also in 90 per cent of the blasts across the country.

"Inviting ISI for probe is like handing over treasury keys to the thief," Munde said.

To Union Home Minister Shivraj Patil's resignation, Munde said that it was 'too late' and Patil should have quit after the Delhi blasts in September last.


How many hours will it take before the Obama Campaign comments that the BJP isn't being helpful, and that George Bush and Dick Cheney have already shown the world the folly of jumping to conclusions.

MV Alpha

1668eb40415f9ee9e1f8613cf71adc35.jpgThe 'Vindhyagiri' (F42), a Leander class frigate, and helicopters from the Naval Air Station, Kunjali were involved in pursuit of the merchant vessel. The MV Alpha, a Vietnamese registered vessel in route to Panama, was intercepted, boarded and searched. The crew were questioned and the ship's papers checked and the vessel released.

There are elections in the very near future in India, and the BJP is doing media buys using the Mumbai mass-murder suicides to attack Congress for "surrendering to terror and accusing it of being "unable and unwilling to deal with terrorism." Basically, running the RNC playbook from the 2002 mid-term and the 2004 general. For its part Congress is toying with blaming "foreign interests", sacking Home Minister Shivraj V Patil and moving Minister P Chidambaram from Finance to Home. Just as the BJP forced Congress into a "unity" government after the 2001 attack on the Parliment, Congress may force the BJP into some "unity" arrangement to limit the use of the mass-murder suicides in electoral politics.

The Obama/Biden Transition Team have an opportunity, not to make "there's only one president at a time but you have our sympathies" calls, but to detail what went wrong with the US response to mass-murder suicides seven years ago, and what India should not do, which is what Bush/Cheney did do.

Juan Cole thought about this too overnight and has a post worth reading twice, India: Please Don't Go Down the Bush- Cheney Road.

There are really important issues here. What do American voters hope Indian voters will choose at the ballot box? It wasn't a non-issue for non-American voters what American voters did just four short weeks ago. What do American voters hope Pakistani voters chose? Yet another failed intra-dictator period of pathetic "democracy"? What do American voters hope Iranian voters will choose at the ballot box? Do American voters prefer bellicosity or cooperation? It shouldn't be too hard for the next President, the next Vice President, the next Secretary of State, to suggest trust and hope are better choices than anger and fear, and war is a genie that never goes willingly back into the bottle, and a million lives were lost because Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld exercised poor judgement as the elected leaders of a highly armed, temporarily failed, democracy, which we all hope to change.

November 29, 2008

Opening a second front

"Pakistan will divert troops to its border with India and away from fighting militants on the Afghan frontier, if tensions erupt in the wake of the attacks on Mumbai, a senior Pakistani security official said on Saturday."

Yes. That's why. I've been trying to explain this and this quote just fell into my lap. via Dawn.

Non-good non-cooperation

BBC (Urdu) has reported that the Pakistani cabinet meeting today has decided that no personnel from the Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) will be sent to India "until solid proof of Pakistan's alleged involvement in the Mumbai attacks is provided".

The ISI are world famous as bad actors, and if their senior leaders aren't available for forensics, there will be doubt. From Afghanistan to Kashmir to Baluchistan, India and Pakistan have been fencing, and this just isn't good.

A knock on the door

Vittorio de Filippis edited Libération for five months earlier this year, and Friday moring at 6:40am he was woken by a knock on his door.

It gets ugly fast. A petty defamation claim is the origin.

To read: Journal d'un avocat.

An Evening of Arabic Typography

I've spent at least half my waking hours since mid-afternoon of the 17th, when the proposal to ban any but one of the Latin, Arabic-Indic, and Eastern Arabic-Indic digits in any DNS label was made to the IETF's IDNAbis WG, on Arabic Script and Arabic Script Typography.

I'd seen mixed Latin and Arabic-Indic in Cairo. I learned to read Arabic digits reading license plates which are (on plates only a few years old) dual texts. The "never ever" scope of the proposal seemed to misstate to my credulous peers (the definition of "internationalization expert" in most ASCII-centric computing corporations is the first Asian coder at hand) a couple of conflated issues.

Here's something anyone with bandwidth and an interest in literacy, anybody's literacy, should sit through. An Evening of Arabic Typography.

As one of my correspondents from Tehran noted after scores of frequently more difficult than necessary interactions on two overlapping lists:

There seems to be a divide in list between Arab and Persian view points on various matters which really has nothing to do with being Arab or Persian. The point is that all our Arab colleagues are governmental people (mostly coming from the regulatory body); they're used to ordering people around and telling the customers what they can register. In our case, being non-governmental, we have to serve the customers and are perhaps more sensitive to their needs.

As it that weren't enough fun, Google has an effort underway for Emoji (絵文字), or "picture characters", the graphical versions of :-) and its friends, are widely used and especially popular among Japanese cell phone users.

Uses of Arabic Script, ranging from spray paint on junk cars to high-end arabic typography, and what characters we allow in domain names is non-trivial, and our choices are authority (excluding things like Emoji) and its non-adherents. Perhaps authority and its non-celebrants.

At least my eyes aren't bleeding. When I reviewed Siksika (hi mom!), the Crees (note the plural, you don't want to know about the w-dot and dot-w boundary in Cree, let alone the Eastern Cree Syllabics -- Th-Cree, n-dialect, ... and Western Cree Syllabics -- Y-Cree boundary, which isn't in the same place), Carrier/Dené, and Inuktitut my eyes were definitely bleeding.

The Democrat Free Zone

The E-Wing, 3rd floor. No Democrats need apply for the following:

  1. Secretary of Defense (Robert Gates I)
  2. Deputy Secretary of Defense (Gordon England II)
  3. Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence (James Clapper III)
  4. Under Secretary of Defense for Policy (Eric Edelman III)
  5. Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition, Technology and Logistics (John Young II)
  6. Secretary of the Army (Preston Geren II)
  7. Secretary of the Air Force (Vacant II)
  8. Secretary of the Navy (Donald Winter II)
  9. Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness (David Chu III)
  10. Under Secretary of Defense (Comptroller) (Tina Jonas III)
  11. Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Technology (James Finley III)
  12. Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, and Deputy (Michael Dominguez IV)

The Plum Book has twenty pages of political appointments in the Department of Defense. The likelihood of staffing the DoD with people who are profoundly prudent and reflective on the issue of use of force while the civilian leadership remains profoundly imprudent and non-reflective on that issue is left as an exercise for the reader.

Would you want to risk the next eight years of your policy making life somewhere between E and A knowing that the Special Ops koolaid clowns are still running the show, and every hideously bad idea, from the missile defense "multiple kill vehicle" program to the reliable replacement warhead program and the robust nuclear earth penetrator program, were still sucking up resources and preventing any meaningful reform?

Not only no prosecutions, but no lessons learned, and no reform necessary, because ... its all be so utterly wonderful and success is in the air!



Foreach congressional district with an outcome significant military and allied demographic, foreach Republican incumbent or Republican challenger, the candidate, the campaign, and the RNCC can message in 2010 that there were lessons to be learned from the Bush/Cheney/Rumsfeld disaster and that the Democrats haven't learned those lessons and are just muddling on when radical reforms and bright Republicans are what's really needed.

Keeping Gates means we get creamed in a bunch of districts in two years, districts we should pick up because the whole "agile unguided spear thingee" was brain-dead from get-go, and it keeps the myth going that Dems can't find safety, the purpose of defense, now or ever, and the "peace wing" of the Party can just go back to Russia.

November 28, 2008

The hole in the doughnut

Operational groups acquire vessels capable of conducting intercept, accomplish intercepts, from Somalia to the Gulf of Aden. Now, a merchant vessel was used to intercept a trawler, and after its crew was liquidated, the trawler used to carry out a complex operation at Mumbai.

The US obtained a "lease" of Diego Garcia (7°25' S, 72°25'E), a stationary aircraft carrier. Someone else has a "lease" on a Sargasso Sea, over the horizon from the several Corsair Coasts. A sea where any vessel can become any other vessel, where any cargo or purpose can change, itself and its destination.

Throughout the Second Hundred Years' War, the British Fleets kept watch over the coast of France the Continent. Former SecDef Donald Rumsfeld's, and his SecNav, now Deputy Secretary of Defense Gordon R. England, who assists the current Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates, had no use for a fleet that could hold any coast, any Sargasso Sea, and instead opted for the Saudi Coast Guard.

Indifferent to policy, on 20 January, the SecNav should have clear instructions for the disposition of CTF-150 and the general purpose of Maritime Security Operations, and the hole in the doughnut filled.

IGF Hyderabad

Several of the people I was on the ICANN policy call on the 27th are traveling to Hyderabad, India, for the IGF. At several points I thought I'd be traveling to Hyderabad as well (just the thought makes by butt ache), for several interrelated reasons, but one of my co-workers is attending, so the attacks in Mumbai (Bombay) worried me. The IGF website was updated overnight with this:

The IGF Secretariat of the Internet Governance Forum is saddened by the tragic events of Mumbai and offers its sympathies to the families of the victims and the wounded, and its solidarity with the authorities and people of India.

The Secretary-General has issued a message of sympathy and support.

The IGF meeting in Hyderabad will go ahead as scheduled.

We take the safety of participants very seriously and the UN security team is working closely with the Indian police in order to provide as safe an environment as can be.

November 27, 2008

Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh’s address to India

Dear Citizens,

The dastardly terror attacks that took place in Mumbai last night and today leading to the loss of many precious lives and injuries to many others have deeply shocked the nation. I strongly condemn these acts of senseless violence against innocent people, including guests from foreign countries. I offer my deepest condolences to the bereaved families and sympathies to those injured. The Government will take all necessary measures to look after the wellbeing of the affected families, including medical treatment of injured.

The well-planned and well-orchestrated attacks, probably with external linkages, were intended to create a sense of panic, by choosing high profile targets and indiscriminately killing foreigners.

I salute the courage and patriotism of the police officers, including the Chief of the Anti-Terror Squad, Shri Hemant Karkare and men who have laid down their lives in fighting these terrorists. I assure the country that we will attend in an urgent and serious manner to police reform so that the law and order authorities can work unitedly, effectively and in a determined manner to tackle such threats to national integrity.

We are not prepared to countenance a situation in which the safety and security of our citizens can be violated with impunity by terrorists. It is evident that the group which carried out these attacks, based outside the country, had come with single-minded determination to create havoc in the commercial capital of the country.

We will take the strongest possible measures to ensure that there is no repetition of such terrorist acts. We are determined to take whatever measures are necessary to ensure the safety and security of our citizens.

Instruments like the National Security Act will be employed to deal with situations of this kind. Existing laws will be tightened to ensure that there are no loopholes available to terrorists to escape the clutches of the law. Most importantly, it is essential to immediately set up a Federal Investigation Agency to go into terrorist crimes of this kind and ensure that the guilty are brought to book.

We will take up strongly with our neighbours that the use of their territory for launching attacks on us will not be tolerated, and that there would be a cost if suitable measures are not taken by them. We will take a number of measures to strengthen the hands of our police and intelligence authorities. We will curb the flow of funds to suspect organizations. We will restrict the entry of suspects into the country. We will go after these individuals and organizations and make sure that every perpetrator, organizer and supporter of terror, whatever his affiliation or religion may be, pays a heavy price for these cowardly and horrific acts against our people.

In this hour of tragedy, I appeal to the people to maintain peace and harmony so that the enemies of our country do not succeed in their nefarious designs. All concerned authorities are on alert and will deal sternly with any attempts to disturb public order.

I am confident that the people of India will rise unitedly to face this grave challenge to the nation’s security and integrity.

Jai Hind !

November 26, 2008

Music to my ears

Kurt Prinz, ICANN's Senior VP of Services, in response to my question about the costs of the proposed dispute resolution processes for "legal rights" objections and "community" objections, says

... a community based TLD really goes to the misappropriation, I would put, goes to the misappropriation of a community label which causes that community to object.
This was the insiders concall, GNSO Council, registry operators, and the usual suspects, with more than 50 of us on the call, and not a word was spoken in the next 115 minutes which suggested that communities should not have the opportunity to file objections to the appropriation by others of their names or other significant identifiers, and that the "community" objection process was as determinative to misappropriation as the "legal right" objection process is for marks infringement.

Its been almost 10 years, but there it is, a right we didn't have is now accepted process.

Actually I was asking a cost justification question as both the "legal rights" and "community" objection processes seem to deal with "substantial" and "significant" standards, and while ICANN's proposed to use WIPO for "legal rights" and the International Chambers of Commerce for "community" (as well as "public morality") objections, and the proposed costs are wicked dissimilar, with a marks right being much cheaper to uphold than a non-marks right.

Pequot.com, CrazyHorseMaltLiquor.com, Cherokee.com, ... now none of those are going into the DNS root, at least, not as cultural appropriations commercial or trademark plays.

It got better as the call went on. We're getting alot of the harsh edges towards community identified applications smoothed, and we're still working on the cost issue. And after two wicked civil and productive hours by the usual suspects, we still have two sections of the draft to take questions on, so another call next week.

I'm pretty happy, I can see all my eggs hatching and the chicks making it to flight.

November 25, 2008

Day of Truth: Aubry or Royal

Today the recount commission begins its work. Its been a very bad week to be a French Socialist, and before the week is out, it could be worse. There may be two French Socialist parties.

Ségolène Royal's campaign has moved beyond recount, they've demanded the vote for first secretary of the Socialist Party be annulled even before the recount commission begins its work. Their position is that the current process has no use or legitimacy.

Martine Aubry's campaign continues to express confidence in the process of validating the ballots already underway.
2052_225803-01-08_jpg_0KAUHPRC.JPG

I greatly prefer Aubry, but this photo is a tutorial on how not to let your candidate look in an environment of latent, or actual, press misogyny.

November 24, 2008

Today's notable boats

The Kirov class cruiser Pyotr Velikiy and the Udaloy class destroyer Admiral Chabanenko and two additional vessels and five aircraft are now operating in Venezuelan waters. Prior art is Bay of Lipstick.
peter-the-great.jpgadmiral_chabanenko_exeter.jpg
Just in time for Air Force One routing on the return leg from Lima.

Today's notable birds

A pileated woodpecker, a blue heron, and a kingfisher. All in a short walk before doing dishes.

November 23, 2008

Candidate sought for GNSO representatives to ICANN Geographic Regions WG

380px-OECD-memberstates.pngI was just asked to submit an application for the GNSO's representatives to ICANN Geographic Regions WG. I sent the following which I'd written a month ago in a Constituency context.

Let me state what I see are issues:

1. citizenship is not necessarily coincident with residence, my initial point. A person who left Ethiopia as a youth and living in California ever since is a poor choice for "the voice of Africa". This is not a hypothetical.

2. I think Israel is in the same part of the world as Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Egypt. However, Israel choses to identify as part of Europe. Do we have any interest in, that is, _do_we_benefit_by_, forcing one model of region or another on parties seeking to stand for diversity determined responsibilities? Its not just Israel, also Turkey, Azerbaijan and Uzbekistan identify as "Europe", at least for sports. Where is New Caledonia or Tahiti? How about Guyane?

To use the usual mantra, ICANN should not be in the business of defining geographic regions against the will of those folks. Let them choose whether they wanted to vote in one region or another. ICANN should not be telling them what they are, but telling them that they should opt for one and only one description. Something along the lines of "bottom up" vs "top down" is appropriate here.

3. The pseudo-geograpical approach has been problematic from the begining. Requiring someone from the fictitcious AP region normally means having someone from Australia or New Zealand. Try and wrap your head around the idea that because Paul and Peter are Antipodeans, ICANN is therefore an Asian-centric organization. ICANN determining that Peter, Paul, Bruce and Adrian are "Asians", not "Europeans", is simply bizarre. Did I mention the problem isn't hypothetical?

Now for the cure:

We have adequate representation from the brightly light parts of the world city-to-city link map, which Fred Baker was kind enough to point out to me at Paris. Fred's worked (charity) on getting infrastructure into Kabul, and parts of Africa, as do I.

Here's the URL for the world city-to-city link map.

ICANN is staffed primarily from the OECD states. The existing "diversity" requirement has been gamed throughout ICANN's existence to favor rich, well-connected Anglo-Saxons from all over the world. We need to restate the requirement towards material diversity, not fictional diversity, towards some goals of folks, staff or elected, coming from non-OECD countries, the darker parts of that map.

The UN's model doesn't fit our needs, which is convenient because we _don't_ benefit by pretending treaty organization regionalism is an adequate representation of diversity of network penetration and availability.

So, to a first order, our goal should be half of staff and half of elected roles are the responsibilities of persons from (and not in the remote past either) the non-OECD economies, because our present model is "only token participation, as staff or elected", by persons from anything but OECD economies.

Our market is pretty darn good in the OECD market. Where we need help growing our market is in the non-OECD market, and last I looked, 2/3rds of the world's population are in non-OECD countries, and the cost of a domain name is still within the envelope for a huge user base all now well served with cheap cell phones that are already web enabled.

What we're doing isn't making us as much money as doing something else.



First Transatlantic 40G IP-Router--(optics only)--IP-Router link

Peter was the first person I spoke with when I got to the venue hotel Sunday evening. He was working on this and today made the following announcement:

Just want to announce for the history record that last week we did OC768/STM256 NY/USA-Lulea/SE using routers with integrated optics all the way. Longest hopp was SeaGirt to Blabjerg at some 7500km using RZ-DPSK modulation on the underwater cable.

Interface facing submarine cable in Denmark when link came up..

POS0/5/0/0 is up, line protocol is up
Interface state transitions: 235948
Hardware is Packet over SONET/SDH
Description: "TAT14 Chan 14, fiber 2 to SeaGirt"
Internet address is 192.108.195.29/30
MTU 4474 bytes, BW 39813120 Kbit
reliability 255/255, txload 14/255, rxload 0/255
Encapsulation HDLC, crc 32, controller loopback not set, keepalive not set
Last clearing of "show interface" counters 00:20:14
30 second input rate 145190000 bits/sec, 33312 packets/sec
30 second output rate 2277465000 bits/sec, 333788 packets/sec
38828898 packets input, 20633312397 bytes, 10 total input drops
0 drops for unrecognized upper-level protocol
Received 0 runts, 0 giants, 0 throttles, 0 parity
10 input errors, 10 CRC, 0 frame, 0 overrun, 0 ignored, 0 abort
325196864 packets output, 276372852009 bytes, 0 total output drops
0 output errors, 0 underruns, 0 applique, 0 resets
0 output buffer failures, 0 output buffers swapped out


--Peter


Peter's mom Sigbritt is the non-mythical 75 year old random person with a 40 Gigabits per second connection to her house. Peter was working semi-feverishly to get the code working within the 8 hour scheduled maintenance window his test was allotted, a time slice worth about $125,000 in tarriffed traffic.

Data rates are much higher, and prices much lower, in many of the OEDC countries, than they are in the US.

During the Plenary Peter walked around with a camera shooting with such detachment from the surroundings that I thought of Jonah.

Transitions and other things that might not work

An acquaintance I see regularly at meetings was pleased as punch to borrow my laptop and browse through the Plum Book. I couldn't quite bring myself to share his enthusiasm for the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency billets:


Director, Defense Advanced Research Project Agency, Anthony J. Tether, NA ES
Special Assistant, Operations Liaison, Career Incumbent, CA ES
General Counsel Vacant, ES
Special Assistant for Space, Career Incumbent, CA ES
Comptroller, Career Incumbent, CA ES
Special Assistant for Strategy and Planning, Career Incumbent, CA ES

But that's mid-page-10, of the 20 pages of the Plum Book given to the Department of Defense, and while my acquaintance is a recovering Republican, and doing rather well in industry after a stint at a 501(c)(3) that pays its executives fairly well, we really can do better than leave these two billets unexamined:

Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates, PAS EX I
Deputy Secretary of Defense Gordon R. England, PAS EX II

While the SecDef takes the same oath of office as any officer, to the Constitution, not to an office holder, the job really is political -- to support the policies of the President which require military means. The office of the Presidency has been held by a man who started two wars, neither of which met the tests for legitimacy, but the primary policy of the Executive has been re-election of its party in 2004 and 2006 and 2008. The Invasion, The Trial and Retribution, and finally The Surge. The primary mission of the officers and enlisted service men and women has been to obtain domestic political ends for the Republican party.

Is the Obama/Biden "plan" to continue to use the military for domestic theater? To stage "successful outcomes" every 18 months and ensure partisan goals are achieved every 24 months?

If so, then there's no reason to change the SecDef job, and while England let the prior SecDef run amok with the Navy, that is his primary qualification as Deputy SecDef, to make politics happen by military means.

But the job of planning and executing the series of movement orders that will end the illegal war, a complex ballet affecting 200,000 personnel in Occupied Iraq and the rest of CENTCOM's AOR, is a real job, not one to be sidelined while keeping the fiction of "useful defense intelligence" in a war that survived the repudiation of its authors and its ongoing, until three weeks ago, domestic political purpose.

There must be someone who will work to the best of her, or his, abilities to end the illegal presence of US forces in Iraq, and that is the best choice for SecDef. It could be Barbara Lee, it could be Dennis Kucinich, it could be others. It could not be Robert Gates.

November 22, 2008

Privacy and its Commercial Celebrants

Ari Schwartz (CDT), Danny Weitzner (W3C) and Adam Palmer (PIR) are all on Jules Polonetsky's (DoubleClick, now Google) new privacy thingee. I remember when Jules was Chief Privacy Officer and Special Counsel at DoubleClick. We used to face off in the IAB (Internet Advertising Board, not Internet Architecture Board) calls and the W3C P3P Specification Working Group calls every week.

I also remember that after 9/11 the "Chief Privacy Officer" was about as welcome an idea in Occupied North America as Chief Indian Officer.

So I guess this means that 9/11 is over, and business is back to having to make non-security cases for unlimited access to Personally Identifying Information (PII).

That's a win if you didn't get it. And those of us who weren't asked, most of the P3P effort, are kind of instantly public for not having been asked to be private.

At the Apps Area Open meeting in Minneapolis we discussed Oauth, and more generally, the W3C's new, and oddly incoherent notion spatial location and privacy, relative to the P3P work, or the IETF GeoPriv work. I've a GeoPriv task to review and propose modifications consistent with my prior data collection policy phrase in the EPP spec, or the compact policies phrase in the P3P cookie spec.

As if that weren't enough cookie dough, the undying cookie spec has deltas that, siren like, called out to me again.

Quick. How many Web2.0 mechanisms to steal state, aka session data, aka personally identifying information, can you think of? HTTP Cookies? Good. JavaScript? Good. Flash? Good. ... Its an inobvious list.

Another Abramoff Conviction, one of 15 queued up

Trevor L. Blackann entered a plea yesterday to making a false statement on his 2003 tax returns by failing to report as income about $4,100 in illegal gifts that he received from Jack Abramoff. Blackann was a legislative assistant in the House and Senate for Missouri Sen. Christopher S. "Kit" Bond and Rep. Roy Blunt, both Republicans.

Blackann admitted receiving gifts from three lobbyists in 2003, including a free trip to attend the first game of the 2003 World Series. That trip included airline travel to and from New York City, transportation around the city in a chauffeured sport utility vehicle, a ticket to the game, a souvenir baseball jersey, admission to and entertainment at a gentlemen's club following the game and free meals and drinks.

Here's the plea.

Where's Hoder?

I've been reading Hoder for years and I'm bothered that he may have been taken into custody.

via The Skeptic الشكاك.

CA-04 Recount

This is another race we offered to work, with the assumption that the race would be won or lost on the field. Lots of back and forth with the senior staff during the fire season and last spring, but no interest. They got their field and didn't need us. The Brown campaign is down by 500 votes with almost all of the recounts in from all the counties, so its wicked unlikely the McClintock campaign won't be sending its candidate to Washington.

Fortunately, like the OH-15, it doesn't really matter, outside of the districts, which party won and which party lost. The House Caucus margin is very secure, and for each, the challenger has lost twice.

Two Abramoff contaminated seats, recovered by the GOP. Kudus GOP candidates and senior staff! Well played!

The Court of Appeals has granted plaintiffs' petition to appeal the district court's August 7, 2008 memorandum

Upon consideration of the plaintiffs' petition for permission to appeal pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b), the defendants' response thereto and petition for permission to appeal pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b), the plaintiffs' reply in support of their petition and opposition to the defendants' petition, and the defendants' reply in support of their petition, it is ...

ORDERED that the petitions for permission to appeal be granted.

The position of the United States is that no monies are owed the Cobell plaintiff class.

In January, Judge James Robertson ruled it was "impossible" to perform a historical accounting of the Individual Indian Money trust. We take that as an invitation to pursue the corporate records of payments to the IIM trust, which thus far the Cobell legal team has not attempted.

November 21, 2008

Aubry or Royal

20081121aubryroyalinside.jpg

It isn't often there is a political contest, or a policy choice, where the contestants, the figureheads, the universe of choice, is two women.

I'm hoping its Martine Aubry, not Ségolène Royal, and its 50-50 tonight.

OH-15 recount

U.S. District Judge Algenon Marbley ordered yesterday that provisional ballots cast in Franklin County have to be counted. Stivers' lead has grown to 479, so to be competitive, the Kilroy Field organization would have had to turn out a 2-1 margin of voters in Franklin County who were only allowed to cast provisional ballots.

In spite of the fact that MB hired almost all of the Kilroy Field organization, including her replacement, and revised a crappy Field Plan, execution of the Field Plan for the last 90 days of the campaign was something she left to the people who wouldn't listen to her and were stuck in the bottom of quite a few bottles. Guyz fueled by Alcohol and a big check from the DCCC. So a 2-1 margin of pull that was voted as provisional is wicked unlikely.

The ruling was appealed and provisional-vote counting was put on hold for another week. I'm tempted to send them all bottles of cheap gin as consolation prizes. Some people prefer to wake up hung-over than wake up winners.

The Joint Experts' Statement on Iran

At the Cairo ICANN meeting I sat down to chat with someone from the .sy (Syria) registry, just as I had at a prior ICANN with someone from the .ps (Palestine) regsitry. At the Paris ICANN meeting I spoke at length with someone from the .ir (Iran) registry, which unfortunately was not possible at the Cairo meeting as his getting a visa proved impossible, just as getting visas for 30+ Chinese engineers was impossible for IETF-73 in Minneapolis. However, we communicate regularly, just as thousands of other communicating pairs of people located in North America and Iran. My work has me thinking hard on things like Arabic, Farsi, Urdu and how digits are represented, so this lovely piece of art gets a second showing.

The JESI is correct that the portion of the Cheney/Bush catastrophe which it describes as "campaigns against the Taliban and al-Qaeda" has caused and continues to cause human suffering and losses to civilization on a scale equivalent to the periods we call the Pol Pot Regime or the Rwanda Genocide, though the JESI's choice of terminology, "weakens U.S. national security" is profoundly incorrect. The JESI's next rhetorical device, the second half of a two-themed opening problem statement, was written in a suburb of Tel Aviv, not a suburb of Chicago or New York. The JESI are free to reject the plain language of the Non-Proliferation Treaty and assert that Iran may not ever fabricate reactor fuel from uranium ore, but they can't call that American foreign policy.

We fabricate reactor fuel, a bad idea but never the less, USEC exists as a creation of the American state, see the American Centrifuge Demonstration Facility, Portsmouth plant, Piketon, Ohio, just as we manufacture automobiles, and we don't hint at bombing Korean and Japanese car plants or overthrowing their elected governments. Its not American public policy to start wars to preserve monopoly, though American governments have done just that, as the present Regime has, prior to being overthrown, as the present Regime has been.

The JESI makes five points:

1. Replace calls for regime change with a long-term strategy
2. Support human rights through effective, international means
3. Allow Iran a place at the table - alongside other key states - in shaping the future of Iraq, Afghanistan and the region.
4. Address the nuclear issue within the context of a broader U.S.-Iran opening
5. Re-energize the Arab-Israeli peace process and act as an honest broker in that process

The first is beyond obvious. However, the JESI fails to suggest that, now that we've put the Bush/Cheney Regime on notice that they must surrender on January 20th, we can reach past the creature that Regime created. The 2005 Presidential election was greatly influenced by Bush/Cheney saber rattling, resulting in the surprising, and contested margin of Mahmoud Ahmadi Nejad (2d place with 5,710,354) over Mehdi Karroubi (3rd place with 5,066,316) in the first round, and the landslide in the second round over
Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani (1st place with 6,159,452), and the winning message, Mahmoud Ahmadi Nejad's, restated in his inaugral speach were poverty and the needs of the poor, and the need for the nuclear weapons states to reduce the stockpiles of weapons of mass distruction.

If those, poverty and the needs of the poor, and the need for the nuclear weapons states to reduce the stockpiles of weapons of mass distruction, aren't easy drop-ins to President Elect Obama's January 20th message, we don't need "Regime Change" in Tehran, we still need it in Washington City. And we should be looking to the parties contesting the 2009 Presidential election, just as we expect Ahmadi Nejad, and others, to look past the Bush/Cheney Regime to the Obama/Biden transition team.

reading-lolita.jpg
The second assumes facts not in evidence, or rather, the whole Reading Lolita in Tehran thing (note the cover art was cropped for the American Patriotic Market). This "rationale" became "liberate women through B-52 strikes and keep them free by killing wedding parties" practice of the ISAF (Regional Commands North, RC(W), RC(C), RC(S) and the 101st Joint Task Force Regional Command (East).

We need to remember that there was an American program of social development and progress before the Savior (of women, or individuals) Cult hijacked US Aid.

The third point is sort of droll. We're going to "allow" the Islamic Republic to be able to effect policy goals that involve adjacent states? Try stating the converse without blowing milk, or the beverage at hand, out your nose.

The fourth point is a non-point. If weapons, then the context is regional weapons inventories, so India, Pakistan, China, Russia, and Israel. If non-weapons, then the context is NPT.

The last point is what should have been the first point. What the $#%@! are we going to do about the Zionists and their need for tension to keep their captive populations voting for one of the Zionist parties?

The Joint Experts' Statement on Iran isn't any readier for prime time than Wes Clark's notion that if we just turned over the Tribal Autonomous Regions of Pakistan to the Saudis, all our problems would be solved. It may be all the AIPAC Wing of the Democratic Party, electoral and executive can manage, but it isn't enough to really free us from the grip of crap that Al Gore and Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter have tried to free us from since Dwight Eisenhower abandoned Harry Truman's position on British ownership of Iranian oil and authorized Operation Ajax to overthrow the government of Prime Minister Mohammed Mosaddeq and his cabinet.

And we're the ones that have to free ourselves, not some poor Democratic centerists trying to triangulate their way to political safety.

November 20, 2008

And Michael Moore is Fat

Automakers never listened to workers, consumers.

King: What do you want them to do now?

Moore: President-Elect Obama has to say to them, yes, we're going to use this money to save these jobs, but we're not going to build these gas-guzzling, unsafe vehicles any longer.

We're going to put the companies into some sort of receivership and we, the government, are going to hold the reigns on these companies. They're to build mass transit. They're to build hybrid cars. They're to build cars that use little or no gasoline.


The alternative, as I noted after a dinner where "Democrats" discussed the merits of tax incentives for producers and consumers to make progress towards CAFE goals, is to just let "Democrats" continue to execute GOP policy. See Table Manners.

November 19, 2008

The Guy Sitting Next To Me

ietf73-plenary.jpg

It is the Technical Plenary, and there's about a thousand of us in the hall. He had a "first IETF" badge on, so I introduced myself and asked a few questions. He'd attended the low power routing working group meeting. Then I asked more questions. Then I asked more questions. Then I asked to see his presentation. Then I asked him to take my card and to email me his presentation. He'd gotten 300+km distance using commercial off-the-shelf wifi kit. I just thought "Dinétah, Northern Roadless Canada, ..."

And he just got asked to come to the podium and accept the Jon Postel Service Award for 2008. Professor Emanno Pietrosemoli of the Fundacion Escuela a Latinoamericanana de Redes. For pioneering network testbeds in rural Africa and South America.

Photos when I get them. They are kwel!

60 Days of Fall

The Dow went under 8,000 today.

Mascots and Majorities

111608_96401_1116locanextdance.jpgThere exists an organization which is has been granted the status of a "registered student organization" by the University of Illinois. The purpose of the organizers is to promote an imaginary character, a skit, a dance routine, executed by a single actor in costume with some props.

We tend to see this kind of thing one way, and Robert Warrior rose to the occasion at Illinois [ 1, 2 ].

But another way occurred to me, I suppose because of the number of times I've seen this series of films. The kids like them, heck, I like them.




MV5BMTIxMTg3ODA1NF5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwMTkzMDEyMQ@@._V1._SX96_SY140_.jpg
bring-it-on-again-2006.jpg
bring-it-on-2007.jpeg
bring-it-on-all-or-nothing.jpeg

Why is this show, this absurdly unaesthetic, imaginary character, executing a rote skit, consisting of an absurdly poorly choreographed dance routine, executed by a single, not very athletic actor in costume with some props, competitive with a squad of athletes, female and male, executing demanding and well choreographed routines that are peer reviewed and highly competitive? How does a lounge act, a comedy skit without dialog, something that will never make it, will never be performed by an artist on his or her last legs, will never be good enough to merit self-parody, displace the best work of the Illinois Cheerleading squads?

Restated, why do some students prefer to see the lounge act rather than the game show? Do the athletes who perform cheer routines want to give their time to the non-athlete and his routine? Is this just "anti-Indian" (and of course it is anti-Indian) or is it also anti-performance? Anti-excellence? Anti-athleticism? Is it fake dance against real dance?

Minnisota Recount

The recount begins today. I'm in Minneapolis for the 73rd IETF, and the mailing list is in semi-melt over the disclosure that once again a substantial number of visa applications from engineers in China have been held up. Fred Baker writes:


I spoke with colleagues at Tsinghua last night. Apparently some 30 people that had intended to come from China were unable to for visa reasons. The issue is basically the US Embassy; they have historically gone out of their way in what appears to be a concerted effort to make Chinese travel to the US difficult. Last year I brought a post-doc from Xian to give a talk, and the embassy process took a couple of months including rewriting the letter of support to include a specific sequence of words that appeared to be important to someone.
I wrote also:
Returning from the Montevideo ICANN meeting, on September 10th, 2001, the person seated next to me to Chicago was the Government Advisory Council (GAC) representative from the PRC. He recounted to me that he was unable to use his normal passport to attend post-graduate course work in the US, and had to resort to his diplomatic passport, and, that the pattern of visa denials had sharply increased after January 20th, 2000, and worsened after 1 April 2001.
The range of fixes is basically (a) hope that the incoming elected administration reduces the level of the obvious targeted and racist pseudo-zenophobia to zero, to be determined at the San Francisco IETF next Spring, or the 2010 Spring meeting, or (b) move the venue of North American meetings from occasionally Canada to preferentially Canada.

I hope for (a), but (b) is the more prudent choice. It is important for states to know that international technical meetings have requirements that cannot be waived by appeals to military necessity, particularly belligerent states. Cost and Consequences.

Ed Foley who teaches at Moritz and runs the election law program there has a good essay in today's Star Tribune on the '62 recount and the process then, and now in the Coleman-Franken recount. He manages to mention that some felt that the USSC's 5-4 split in Bush v Gore was "procedurally illegitimate", without mentioning that the decision can't be cited, and that no one in their right mind would have chosen a dying drug addict and ultra-partisan hack like Rehnquist onto a three-judge panel, which is where the Coleman and Franken legal teams will go if either challenges the decisions of the current State Canvassing Board, and if they don't agree on the three, then each selects one, and those two select a third. A process not likely to garner two dying drug addicted ultra-partisan hacks, or one plus a side-kick.

Like Maine, Minnesota is cleaner than a lot of the US, politically. There's a lot of crap to clean up, and as we posted prior over the Spring and Summer, no small amount of it hails from the anything-goes approach to winning Democratic caucus and primary contests.

November 18, 2008

simple digits

397px-Arabic_numerals-en.svg.pngThe subject of a proposal to the IDNAbis working group is to prevent any label (any part of a domain name bounded by "dots") from having any digits from two or more of these sets, but the first three in particular.

The problem is somewhat non-trivial to state: the visually similar glyphs (0, 1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 9) in the two "Arabic-Indic" forms are different code points, and, some Arabic preference is to only allow Latin (here called "European") and to disallow any "Arabic-Indic" glyphs because they are not "Arabic", and some Arabic preference is to allow one or the other of both "European and "Arabic-Indic", though not necessarily within a single label, and of course the Farsi/Urdu preference is for the Extended Arabic-Indic glyphs, here labeled "Eastern" with the Farsi/Urdu noted also. As if that weren't sufficiently distracting, these are bidirectional, that is, left-to-right characters within all of the right-to-left Arabic Scripts (Arabic, Farsi, Urdu, ...), but that's not the problem, and they could all be "normalized" (a Unicode term of art), but that would just transform one hard problem into another.

GIven that "equal" in arabic is يساوي (YOUSAWI : ي س ا و ي) and "is" in arabic is هو (HOWA: (ه و)


Suppose that:

"lesson.0equals٠.learn-arabic-digits.us" or lesson.۰يساوي0.learn-arabic-digits.us or lesson.۰هو0.learn-arabic-digits.us
...
"lesson.9equals٩.learn-arabic-digits.us" (repeat for يساوي and هو)

are domain names, with some lesson for Arabic learners at each URL suggested by the domain name.

Is this a bad thing?
If "equals" is replaced by "is", is the answer any different?
If the English words such as "equals" or "is" are replaced by Arabic words, is the answer any different?
If the latin digit and the arabic-indic digit are not separated by any non-digit characters, is the answer any different? The code points in Unicode are shown below, there's an obvious reversed direction that I can't figure out how to fix in MT 3.2, which has always been challenged by anything non-ASCII in the first place.

Western Arabic (U+0030..U+0039)
| 0 || 1 || 2 || 3 || 4 || 5 || 6 || 7 || 8 || 9

Middle East Arabic (U+0660..U+0669)
| ٠ || ١ || ٢ || ٣ || ٤ || ٥ || ٦ || ٧ || ٨ || ٩

Eastern Arabic (U+06F0..U+06F9)
| ۰ || ۱ || ۲ || ۳ || ۴ || ۵ || ۶ || ۷ || ۸ || ۹

For your cut and paste joy, the wiki formatted table is below the jump. You've now seen "a hard problem" for internationalization. Its not really that hard, but its passing for one this week and two weeks ago in Cairo.

{| class="wikitable" style="text-align:center;font-size:200%;"
|- style="font-size:50%"
!Western Arabic
! 0 !! 1 !! 2 !! 3 !! 4 !! 5 !! 6 !! 7 !! 8 !! 9
|-
!style="font-size:50%"|Middle East Arabic
| ٠ || ١ || ٢ || ٣ || ٤ || ٥ || ٦ || ٧ || ٨ || ٩
|-
!style="font-size:50%"|Eastern Arabic
| ۰ || ۱ || ۲ || ۳ || ۴ || ۵ || ۶ || ۷ || ۸ || ۹
|}

Blogging in Egypt

antindp_logo.jpgThe English language newspaper I picked up the day before I left Cairo had a photo of several men quite openly setting fire to the headquarters of a political party. Theirs as it happened, the fruit of a faction fight. Far more important was what wasn't covered. I saw it my first hours in Cairo, but I didn't understand what I was seeing. On the road from the airport to Heliopolis there was uniformed, and plainclothes police everywhere. My driver said it was Mubarak, but I didn't realize what was going on. It was Hosni Mubarak’s party holding its annual convention to lay the blueprint of future policies, and to declare the previous year's policies completely accomplished. Very Early Soviet, or Bush/Cheney every-mission-accomplished if that is more to taste.

Marc Lynch has had three posts recently on blogging in Egypt: Democracy in Egypt, AMS: Evolution of Egyptian blogging and about that "freedom agenda".... .

Recommended.

November 16, 2008

In Route

The course of the flight from Atlanta took me between Eilijay, and the Dahlonega Plateau, the smoking gun for the Cherokee Removal.

My luggage wouldn't catch up to me until two days later. The ticket agent in Wilmingon handed me some other passenger's baggage ticket, and my bag went to Syracuse while I went to Minneapolis. I suppose he was a caffine deprived as I.

November 15, 2008

Prop 8 contributors in Monterey County

via the public records of the Secretary of State. There are more of us who love (oppose) than who hate (support), but there are many, many haters. One to the tune of $60,000, and there are several $1,000 clusters -- the organized haters. North up the San Francisco - Los Angeles highway, then along the Santa Lucias to the Pajaro.

Below the fold.

CLAY MURDOCK $1,000 SAN MIGUEL CA 93451 RANCHO SAN MIGUEL Support
CLAYTON C. MURDOCK $1,000 SAN MIGUEL CA 93451 RANCHO SAN MIGUEL Support
RAY HARDEN $100 SAN MIGUEL CA 93451 N/A Support
WILLIAM BARTOSH $50 SAN MIGUEL CA 93451 N/A Oppose
PATTI HAYES $100 LOCKWOOD MO 65682 HAYES PLUMBING, INC. Oppose
MICHAEL ORRADRE $200 SAN ARDO CA 93450 SARGENT CATTLE CO Support
MICHEL ORRADRE $500 SAN ARDO CA 93450 SARGENT CATTLE CO Support
BRENT GREEN $1,000 KING CITY CA 93930 GREEN'S ACCOUNTING Support
CONNIE BAUER $100 KING CITY CA 93930 SAME NAME Oppose
DANIEL LUNT $100 KING CITY CA 93930 KING CITY JOINT USD Support
JANEEL WELBURN $1,000 KING CITY CA 93930 MEE MEMORIAL HOSPITAL Support
REED JACOBS $1,000 KING CITY CA 93930 HARAVEST DATA LINK Support
ANNE SOLOMON-COURREJOU $100 GREENFIELD CA 93927 REQ2008 Oppose
JERRI FRY $150 GREENFIELD IN 46140 WATSON'S Oppose
KIRSTEN SLAMA $100 GREENFIELD CA 93927 N/A Support
LESLIE TANKERSLEY $125 SOLEDAD CA 93960 N/A Support
MATTHEW DOWNEY $150 GONZALES LA 70737 N/A Oppose

ABBY BUKOFZER $100 SALINAS CA 93908 SELF-ABBY BUKOFZER, MS MFT Support
ALAI NAU $100 SALINAS CA 93907 N/A Support
ALLISON HINKLE $100 SALINAS CA 93908 STALEY CONTRUCTION Support
ALTON OGBORN $100 SALINAS CA 93906 N/A Support
ANDREA CARINGAL $100 SALINAS CA 93905 HSBC Support
ANTHONY GRAHAM $100 S ALINAS CA 93901 ALLIANCE SHIPPERS Oppose
BECKI ROSS $100 SALINAS CA 93908 N/A Support
BETTY WEATHERFORD $500 SALINAS CA 93907 N/A Support
BRAD STIMSON $1,000 SALINAS CA 93906 GRANITE ROCK Support
BRIAN ROZEMA $150 SALINAS CA 93908 WALGREENS Oppose
CHRISTINA BATISTICH $1,000 SALINAS CA 93908 N/A Support
DANIEL BOWMAN $1,000 SALINAS CA 93908 N/A Support
DARRIN BRIGHT $250 SALINAS CA 93908 CA TRAINING FACILITY Support
DAVID HIGGINBOTHAM $500 SALINAS CA 93908 SELF-EMPLOYED Support
DAVID LIGARE $100 SALINAS CA 93908 HARTNELL COLEGE Oppose
DAVID RIRIE $250 SALINAS CA 93901 N/A Support
DONALD LOCKE $2,500 SALINAS CA 93908 TOMBLESON Support
DONNA LEE $150 SALINAS CA 93908 MORGAN WINERY, INC. Oppose
DOUGLAS MILLER $100 SALINAS CA 93906 AMERICAN RED CROSS Support
EDWARD POWLEY $250 SALINAS CA 93901 NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL Support
GORDON BABBITT $240 SALINAS CA 93901 N/A Support
GRACE CHUBB $2,500 SALINAS CA 93908 N/A Support
HOWARD MILLER $100 SALINAS CA 93908 PG&E Support
JAMES BUNN $1,000 SALINAS CA 93908 CROWN PACKING COMPANY Support
JAMES CREAGER $400 SALINAS CA 93907 N/A Support
JAMES LUGG $250 SALINAS CA 93901 FRESH EXPRESS Support
JASON STALEY $300 SALINAS CA 93907 STALEY CONSTRUCTION Support
JODIE PRATT $700 SALINAS CA 93908 N/A Support
JOHN CRESS SR. $30 SALINAS CA 93907 VORTECHS Support
JOHN PICHEL $1,000 SALINAS CA 93908 RETIRED Oppose
JOSHUA BATISTICH $500 SALINAS CA 93908 CLASSIC BERRY Support
KATHLEEN PETERS $150 SALINAS CA 93901 UC DAVIS Oppose
KENNETH ANDERSON $250 SALINAS CA 93906 N/A Support
KERRY VARNEY $2,500 SALINAS CA 93908 TANIMMPA & ANTLE Support
L. KEITH SLAMA $500 SALINAS CA 93901 DOORS UNLIMITED Support
LAURA YOUNG $200 SALINAS CA 93906 MONTEREY COUNTY HEALTH DEPARTMENT Oppose
LENORE GREEN $100 SALINAS CA 93901 ALISAL UNION SCHOOL DISTRICT Support
LISA CISNEROS $400 SALINAS CA 93908 CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL ASSISTANCE Oppose
LISA CISNEROS $100 SALINAS CA 93908 CRLA Oppose
LORI PIERCE $100 SALINAS CA 93908 N/A Support
MARCIA SIMMONS $100 SALINAS CA 93901 MARCIA SIMMONS COUNSELING Support
MARK JONES $100 SALINAS CA 93901 TAPP SYSTEMS Support
MELVIN WHITE $350 SALINAS CA 93905 THE HOUSE CALL VET Support
MICHAEL KING $5,000 SALINAS CA 93908 TAIYO PACIFIC PARTNERS Support
PATRICIA BARRETT $100 SALINAS CA 93908 CHURCH OF THE GOOD SHEPHERD Oppose
PAUL STAHLMAN $12,000 SALINAS CA 93906 N/A Support
PEARL BEREMAN $100 SALINAS CA 93908 BEREMAN CARPETS Support
RICHARD ROSS $2,500 SALINAS CA 93908 ROSS ROOFING Support
ROGER CAMPBELL $349 SALINAS CA 93907 TAMBLESON Support
ROGER REINSCH $250 SALINAS CA 93906 H SBC Support
SALLY HEKKERS $100 SALINAS CA 93908 SAME NAME Oppose
SHARAN JOYCE $650 SALINAS CA 93907 MCOE Support
STACY WOODRUFF $250 SALINAS CA 93907 CTB/MCGRAW-HILL Oppose
STEVE LOCKE $500 SALINAS CA 93901 TOMBLESON Support
TODD STALEY $150 SALINAS CA 93907 STALEYS HEATING Support
WESTON GORING $1,000 SALINAS CA 93907 US ARMY Support
WILLIAM JOHNSON $100 SALINAS CA 93901 N/A Support

BARBARA D MOORE $850 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Oppose
BRUCE JOHNSEN $1,000 MONTEREY CA 93940 BRUCE JOHNSON, MANAGEMENT CONSUL Support
CARTER MAGDAYAO $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 MADRAGIL Oppose
CATHAY CIRCUITS, INC. $5,000 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Support
CHINA CIRCUIT TECHCORP $5,000 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Support
CYNTHIA VERNON $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 CARMEL CHAMBER OF COMMERCE Oppose
DANIEL NARANJO $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Support
DAVID BENJAMIN $250 MONTEREY CA 93940 TRIAD BROADCASTING Oppose
DON HUGHES $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 MONTEREY BAY AQUARIUM Oppose
EDITH & STANLEY ROSS $100 MONTEREY MA 1245 N/A Oppose
EILEEN NAZZARO $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
EVAN OAKES $100 MONTEREY CA 93942 AG VENTURE TOURS Oppose
JAMES LAMB $2,500 MONTEREY CA 93940 TAIYO PACIFIC PARTNERS Support
JAMES TOALE $300 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Support
JEANNE TURNER $200 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Oppose
JEFFREY CALHOON $396 MONTEREY CA 93940 NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL Support
JOHN KOOSTRA $1,000 MONTEREY CA 93940 CARDIO-PULMONARY ASSOCIATES MEDICAL GROUP Oppose
JOHN KOOSTRA $500 MONTEREY CA 93940 CPAMG Oppose
JOHN KOOSTRA $300 MONTEREY CA 93940 DYNALECTRIC Oppose
JOHN MATHEWS $250 MONTEREY CA 91320 A-Z CAN Support
JOYCE SHERRY $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 YORK SCHOOL Oppose
JUDY HIGGERSON-PROCIDA $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 COUNTRY HOME CARE Oppose
KELLEY CALVERT $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 MONTEREY INSTITUTE OF INTERNATIONAL STUDIES Oppose
KENNETH PHILLIPS $50 MONTEREY CA 93940 USMC Support
LUKE OVERFELT $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 US NAVY Support
MALCOLM HUFF $400 MONTEREY CA 93940 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
MALCOLM LAIDLAW $100 MONTEREY PARK CA 91754 N/A Support
MARK SOLOMON $225 MONTEREY CA 93940 WATSONVILLE MORTGAGE Support
MATTHEW SIMIS $250 MONTEREY CA 93942 TANIMURA & ANTLE Oppose
MATTHEW SIMIS $250 MONTEREY CA 93942 TANIMURA & ANTLE, INC. Oppose
MICHELLE TORGERSEN $414 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Support
NANCY NIVLING $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
OVERTON $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 US NAVY Support
PAUL CLARK $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 NAVAL POSTGRADYATE SCHOOL Support
RANDOLPH BOYD $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Oppose
RENEE FRANKEN $150 MONTEREY CA 93940 RENEE FRANKEN & ASSOCIATES Oppose
RENEE FRANKEN $500 MONTEREY CA 93940 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
RICHARD MURAKAMI $100 MONTEREY PARK CA 91754 N/A Oppose
ROBERT KERR $150 MONTEREY CA 93944 US ARMY Support
ROBERT NEUBERT $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Oppose
SCOTT MCMILLAN $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 COMMUNITY HOSPITAL - MONTEREY Oppose
SHAE RAINEY $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Support
SHANE JENSON $250 MONTEREY CA 93940 US MARINE CORPS Support
STACY BANKS $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 STUDENT Support
SUSAN KUBICA $300 MONTEREY CA 93940 SAME NAME Oppose
SUSAN KUBICA $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
SUSAN PERRIN $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 REQ2008 Oppose
TALMADGE BAILEY $500 MONTEREY CA 93940 UNITED STATES DEPT OF COMMERCE Oppose
TONY LENOIR $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 N/A Support
TUNG LAUIN $200 MONTEREY PARK CA 91754 SUN MICROSYSTEM Oppose
WILLIAM BOYD $100 MONTEREY CA 93940 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose

JEFF MALLORY $2,190 BIG SUR CA 93920 N/A Oppose
JEFF MALLORY $200 BIG SUR CA 93920 UNEMPLOYED Oppose
MARK SULLIVAN $100 BIG SUR CA 93920 BIG SUR WOODWORKS Support
RICHARD SPENCER $60,000 BIG SUR CA 93923 SELF/DICK SPENCER ASSOCIATES Support

BENSON CARROLL $100 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
CHARLES FINELL $1,000 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 N/A Support
CHRIS HARROLD $100 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 MONTEREY BAY AQUARIUM Oppose
CHRISTINE WILLIAMS $100 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 N/A Support
DENISE ADKINS $198 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 SAME NAME Oppose
JULIE CASON $1,000 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 N/A Oppose
KAREN STRICKLAND $500 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
AMY ANDERSON $500 CARMEL CA 93923 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
BENSON CARROLL $100 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
BETSY COLLINS $300 CARMEL CA 93923 CENTRAL COAST LANGUAGE AND LEARNING CENTER Oppose
BOB BOOKER $100 CARMEL CA 93923 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
CARVER + SCHICKETANZ ARCHITECTS $200 CARMEL CA 93921 SAME NAME Oppose
CHARLES FINELL $1,000 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 N/A Support
CHRIS HARROLD $100 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 MONTEREY BAY AQUARIUM Oppose
CHRISTINE WILLIAMS $100 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 N/A Support
DAVE ALBIOL $1,000 CARMEL CA 93922 SAME NAME Oppose
DAVID KEYSTON $475 CARMEL CA 93921 N/A Support
DENISE ADKINS $198 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 SAME NAME Oppose
GILBERT NEILL $100 CARMEL CA 93921 REQ2008 Oppose
GINA TARO $100 CARMEL CA 93923 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
GREGORU LUND $100 CARMEL CA 93923 LULA'S CHOCOLATES Support
GRETCHEN HAUSMANN $200 CARMEL CA 93923 MONTEREY PENINSULA COLLEGE Oppose
J. ELIZABETH HUSBY $100 CARMEL CA 93923 N/A Oppose
JAMES MEARNS $100 CARMEL CA 93923 CROSS TELECOM Oppose
JAMES MEARNS $125 CARMEL CA 93923 CROSS TELECOM CORP Oppose
JAN MATTHEWS $135 CARMEL IN 46032 ADP Support
JOAN ELIZABETH HUSBY $100 CARMEL CA 93921 RETIRED Oppose
JOAN HUSBY $40 CARMEL CA 93921 N/A Oppose
JOAN HUSBY $20 CARMEL CA 93921 NON-PROFIT SOCIAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATOR Oppose
JOHN MORTELL $100 CARMEL IN 46033 N/A Support
JUDITH TATELBAUM $100 CARMEL CA 93923 SAME NAME Oppose
JUDITH WOLFE $500 CARMEL BY THE SEA CA 93921 SAME NAME Oppose
JULIE CASON $1,000 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 N/A Oppose
KAREN STRICKLAND $500 CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
KINGMEN, INC. $200 CARMEL CA 93922 N/A Support
LYNN STOCKMAN $200 CARMEL CA 93921 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
MARGARET R. FULLER $500 CARMEL CA 93923 RETIRED Oppose
MARGOT HANIS $100 CARMEL CA 93923 NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC SCHOOL PUBLISHING Oppose
MARIE SWANSON $100 CARMEL IN 46033 INDIANA UNIVERSITY Oppose
MATHEW SANDERS $250 CARMEL CA 93923 N/A Support
MICHAEL CANEPA $100 CARMEL CA 93923 N/A Support
MICHAEL LYNCH $100 CARMEL CA 93921 SAME NAME Oppose
RICHARD OLIVER $500 CARMEL CA 93923 DIVIDEND HOMES Support
RICHARD SPENCER JR. $5,000 CARMEL BY THE SEA CA 93921 DICK SPENCER & ASSOCIATES Support
ROBERT GETCHELL $5,000 CARMEL CA 93923 N/A Oppose
THOMAS HILLESHEIM $2,000 CARMEL CA 93923 HILLESHEIM Support
VALERA W. LYLES $250 CARMEL CA 93923 THE MUSES Oppose
WARREN LUCH $150 CARMEL CA 93921 N/A Support
WILLIAM FISHER $10,000 CARMEL CA 93023 SAME NAME Oppose
BONNIE WADWORTH $250 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 N/A Support
CARMA DONG $1,000 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 STUART DONG Support
CLEORA ANDERSON $100 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 DIRECTOR, DIVERSITY AND EQUITY Oppose
CREIGHTON PEET $885 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
CREIGHTON PEET $100 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 WRITER Oppose
CRISTINA AMARILLAS $100 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 DENISE R MARK, MD Oppose
DENYSE FRISCHMUTH $100 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 N/A Oppose
FRANCES C BACA $100 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 BIANCHI, KASAVAN & POPE, CPA'S Oppose
JOANNE VELMAN $200 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 SALINASUHSD Oppose
KATHERINE STONER $650 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 SELF Oppose
M LEMMON $1,000 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 NEW STAR Support
MICHELLE WELSH $500 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 SEFL Oppose
NICHOLAS SASSON $100 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 V.A. Oppose
ROBERT GARLAND $1,000 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 N/A Oppose
ROCHELLE HEYWOOD $5,000 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 ROCHELLE HEYWOOD Support
SEAN CONROY $150 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 CITY OF CARMEL Support
SHAWN KUMAGAI $100 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 USN Oppose
TED ALDEN $100 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 ALDEN ENGINEERING Oppose
WALTER CLAUSEN $200 PACIFIC GROVE CA 93950 UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT Oppose
BROOKE GIBSON $100 SEASIDE CA 93955 N/A Support
DANIEL HINKSON $100 SEASIDE CA 93955 USMC Support
DANTZEL RHODES $150 SEASIDE CA 93955 N/A Support
DAVID DOWNEY $500 SEASIDE CA 93955 PEBBLE BEACH COMPANY Oppose
DAVID HOMA $500 SEASIDE CA 93955 ALL AROUND FITNESS Support
ERIN PARR $150 SEASIDE CA 93955 US NAVY Oppose
HEATHER MARTIN $300 SEASIDE CA 93955 N/A Support
JENNIFER CLINCH $500 SEASIDE CA 93955 N/A Support
JENNIFER TENNEY $360 SEASIDE CA 93955 N/A Support
LANCE RONDEAU $100 SEASIDE CA 93955 US AIR FORCE Support
MINDY OLSON $145 SEASIDE CA 93955 N/A Support
NATHAN SHANER $100 SEASIDE CA 93955 MONTEREY BAY AQUARIUM RESEARCH INSTITUTE Oppose
PORTER L BAYMON $100 SEASIDE CA 93955 PORT OF OAKLAND Oppose
REBECCA HETTER $500 SEASIDE CA 93955 RETIRED Oppose
SCOTT MERRILL $100 SEASIDE CA 93955 AIRPORT ROAD SELF STORAGE Support
SUZANNE SPERRY $250 SEASIDE CA 93955 N/A Support
THOMAS LEE $100 SEASIDE CA 93955 US NAVY Oppose
VIKI WHITMER $100 SEASIDE CA 93955 N/A Support

AKONI GANIR $100 MARINA CA 93933 MOWTIME JR Support
ANDREW COILE $100 MARINA CA 93933 CSU MONTEREY BAY Oppose
CATHY BARRETT $550 MARINA CA 93933 ALISAL UNION Support
CHRIS TAYLOR $101 MARINA CA 93933 CSU MONTEREY BAY Support
CHUCK HUGHES $100 MARINA CA 93933 STATE OF CAL Oppose
DOUGLAS HOLTZMAN $200 MARINA CA 93933 CITY OF MONTEREY Oppose
DWIGHT GOEHRING $100 MARINA CA 93933 N/A Oppose
FRED WEHLING $100 MARINA CA 93933 MONTEREY INST OF INTER. STUDIES Support
GEORGE LENNO $500 MARINA CA 93933 CSU MONTEREY BAY Oppose
GILLIAN RHETT $100 MARINA CA 93933 N/A Oppose
JESSE WILLIAMS $500 MARINA CA 93933 STUDENT Support
KAREN WISDOM $100 MARINA CA 93933 CSUMB Oppose
MARLENE TISE $100 MARINA CA 93933 N/A Oppose
MONTEREY SCULPTURE CENTER $2,500 MARINA CA 93933 MONTEREY SCULPTURE CENTER Support
STEVE SHIMEK $100 MARINA CA 93933 THE OTTER PROJECT Oppose
SUZANNE WORCESTER $100 MARINA CA 93933 CA STATE UNIVERSITY Oppose

CONNIE CLENDENEN $50 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 N/A Support
CYNTHIA KERN $100 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 N/A Oppose
CYNTHIA KERN $100 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 UCSC Oppose
DEBORAH HENSLER $2,000 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 STANFORD UNIVERSITY Oppose
DORALINA MACIAS $70 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 WEST MARINE PRODUCTS Support
EDWIN P. POWELL $200 WATSONVILLE CA 95077 RETIRED Oppose
LEILANI BARNETT $150 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 DMB ASSOCIATES Oppose
LOIS SMITH $50 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 N/A Support
MARKS RICHARD B. $200 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 N/A Oppose
MICHAEL FORD $300 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 RETIRED Oppose
NORMAN WELCH $2,300 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 N/A Support
SATORU SUZUKI $1,895 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 CABRILLO COLLEGE Support
SONIA DURAN $1,000 WATSONVILLE CA 95077 DURAN SALES Support
STEVE PISTA $129 WATSONVILLE CA 95077 N/A Support
TERRY VINCENT $200 WATSONVILLE CA 95076 ARNOLD ICHIUJI, DMD Support

JOAN MILLER $200 DEL REY OAKS CA 93940 N/A Support
MAURICE WEIR $200 DEL REY OAKS CA 93940 SAME NAME Oppose
MAURICE WEIR $100 DEL REY OAKS CA 93940 SELF-EMPLOYED Oppose
KATHRYN RICKS $500 SAND CITY CA 93955 CITY OF MONTEREY Support
JUDITH BELL $100 AROMAS CA 95004 SAN JOSE CITY COLLEGE Oppose
KAREN JACHENS $200 AROMAS CA 95004 N/A Oppose
GAYLORD SMITH $100 PRUNEDALE CA 93907 HARTNELL COLLEGE Oppose
MELODIE SOLTON $99 PRUNEDALE CA 93907 MONTEREY CO OFFICE OF EDUC Support

November 14, 2008

Imagining Transition at the BIA, the MMS, the DOI, and the DOJ

Abramoff is ancient history, unless you're a 'skin, in which case Jack's shadow is still doing the rounds between K Street and Interior. So what could transition look like?

For a start, the Nixon, Haldeman, Erlichman model, which is the gold standard, the high-water mark for the Federal-Tribal relationship. Translated into Transition-Speak, coordinating Federal Indian policy stays "close" to the TT, not farmed out to some discrete hire/fires tagged for staffers for the eventual assistant secretary.

In the longer term, the transition could position FI policy as transitioning from Interior, where trees and bears and rocks live, to State, where Other Peoples live.

Next, the TT could spend some quality time with Eloise Cobell. There's a lot folks who haven't followed this for the past decade don't know, and recycled Clinton (Bill) people weren't particularly more clued in than the Bush/Cheney lot of political appointees.

Then there's the MMS. A wicked rich vein of corruption reaching many interesting places, almost all of which were protected by the DOJ in the Sansonetti and Wooldridge comedy of manors and revolving doors.

The TT could staff up the Hill policy desks with someone who owns the PL280 repeal task and get someone serious, Rob Williams comes to mind, to work on unraveling the Rehnquist nightmare that's created rape tourism in Indian Country.

And finally, there's Ross. A man in need of a vacation. Come to think of it Chad could do with one too. Club Fed or not, that's a never mind. But vacated. Gone. In TT speak that's a Special Trustee designated _now_, and the AUSA for the Eastern District of Oklahoma briefed that time on target (the CNO) is expected.

Was this trip necessary?

US to drop Mullah Omar from blacklist

RT Monitoring Desk

WASHINGTON: The US agrees to drop the name of the Taliban leader, Mullah Omar from the terror list ahead of talks with the insurgents, an official says.
"US intends to remove Mullah Omar from the black list in a bid to provide a suitable seedbed for holding contacts with the Taliban," said, the US Deputy Assistant Secretary of State in the Bureau of South and Central Asian Affairs Patrick S Moon. Moon added that during his upcoming visit to Kabul, he will fully support the idea of negotiated settlement with the Taliban militants to end the violence in the region. He also reiterated that the talks with the Taliban insurgents were possible within the Afghan Constitution, Press TV reported.



One thing which divided Juan Cole and I was the Afghan War. He thought it was "the right war at the right time for ..." I honestly don't recall what the phrasing was. I didn't. I thought 9/11 should have been left to InterPol for as long as it takes, that military method is indifferent to, if not hostile to, the accumulation of evidence, forensic and otherwise, unlike police method, and careless casualties and missed force-on-force opportunities, from Tora Bora to the present, were more probable than not, under method A, and less probable than not, under method B, and the crime ought not go uncorrected through error.

So the government of Mullah Omar, in exile, is going to be a party to the Afghan Peace Talks. This is progress, and its a pity the Bush/Cheney Regime inflicted so great a cost, first, on the US, and second, on Afghanistan and Iraq, and third, on Palestine, to get back close to where we could have been seven years ago.

November 13, 2008

A distant object

2208_205919_WX112_jpg_0KAAHJOB.JPG

November 12, 2008

Taxi Truths

I went into a bookstore looking for any surveys of modern Arabic literature in translation, into English or French, I'm not particular. There were none at hand but I was offered Khaled Al Khamissi's "Taxi", and as I was taking taxis twice a day across Heliopolis, my response was "I'll take two, I've a friend."


Twelve

I was chatting with the driver and he turned out to be a long-standing fan of Zamalek football club. When he was young he used to go to the stadium to watch Taha Basri, Mahmoud el-Khawaga, Ali Khalil and frech you players like Hassan Shehata and Farouk Gaafar. This year (this was the winter of 2005) Zamalek was getting beaten by all the teams.

I tried to convert him to an Ahli fan like myself but he told me that Zamalek was in a bad way and kept falling behind so it needed someone to stand by it, not like Ahli, which was up at the top of the league and didn't need anyone to support it. Zamalek was like Egypt he said, we all have to stand by it so that it stops falling behind.

I asked him how we could stand by Egypt.

"We stand by Egypt if we prepare our children for war." he replied. "It's true that ever since he came to power Mubarak has managed to steer the ship so that Egypt hasn't got into any confrontations with anyone. To be frank, good for him, that's the best thing he's done. The Americans tell us to turn right, we turn right; left, we run to the left. That was important in the past so that we could take a breather and the country's economy could pick up a little and we could stand on our own feet. To be honest, the man has been able to save the country from any recession.

"But was is inevitable. The Israelies won't be able to not make war. Peace will kill them and they know that well. They're itching for a fight. They have their eyes on Syria and Iraq and the keep proding Iran and they have set Palestine on fire. They want it ablaze so they can get more money from the Americans and they can make their young people more Zionist. If the Jews felt at ease, they would go back to Europe.

"So in the end they will turn on us again, not tomorrow but it will be the day after tomorrow, so everyone's role in the country is to prepare his son for war, because for sure it's coming. We now have to give our army the same spirit with which I fought when I was in the army between 1968 and 1973.

"I have a relative who's an officer in the army, a very clever officer who went to the Soviet Union on training courses. The army's spent a packet on him and sent him abroad several times to make him highly skilled. Know what that officer is doing now?

"He's working at an armed forces mess in Nasr City. What does he do? He organizes parties and buys food and serves it. They've turned him into a chef in a restaurant. See the disaster when you take an officer on whom the country has spent thousands and thousands and turn him into a waiter. The disaster is that he's happy and delighted with his status now. How long do you think we'll be able to last without a war?"

"I've no idea," I told him.

"In my opinion no more than another 10 or 15 years," the driver continued. "That means I have a son who's 10 years old and when he leaves university, war will have broken out between us and Israel."

He paused a moment, then resumed: "The problem's with them, not with us. They're the ones who won't be able to keep the peace and it's no use us making peace with ourselves. Peace is something we have to make with someone else, isn't it?"

He laughed at his own joke. "Personally, I'm always explaining the situation to my kids so that when the drums beat, their ears will be ready to heed the call," he added.


The problem's with them, not with us. The Israelies won't be able to not make war. They want it ablaze so they can get more money from the Americans and they can make their young people more Zionist. If the Jews felt at ease, they would go back to Europe.

I read this on the plane between Cairo and JFK. The next morning when I managed to find lefty media the big story was Rahm Emmanuel's father's faux pas, about which I care nought. But, the problem's with them, not with us, we don't need "endangered Zion" to maintain our political elite in power, or do we?

November 11, 2008

Something I missed in Cairo

h_4_ill_1117498_763991.jpg

Saturday I was in Gaza and thought about going to Saqqara. There just wasn't the time to do that, so I went to the Al-Azhar Mosque and sat for a while in the central courtyard before dusk.

After dusk I went to the Khan al-Khalili bazaar.

eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month

Watching PBS yesterday evening I was astonished to hear Dr. James Peake, Secretary of the Department of Veterans Affairs, assert that suicides by Iraq/Afghan War combat vets corollates to general life stresses, not PSTD. Here's the link to the News Hour story.

The father of one of Grace's friends from second grade, a corrections officer then employed by Cumberland County, was called up for a year tour at Gitmo and on his return wanted nothing more than to leave Portland, leave his wife, and leave his daughter, to work in a state prison rather than a county jail. To argue that job change and family disintegration would have happened anyway seems perverse, like an employer who argues that employees die on the job because mortality happens, without causation, or that smoking doesn't have a causal connection with cancer death clusters in the smoker cohorts, absent in the control, non-smoking population.

Later this morning I'll call Jim Martin's campaign in Georgia. I'm sure there's a major weapons procurement program, even one feeding the Iron Triangle's ever-ravenous mouths in Georgia, that is a smarter choice to cannibalize than the post-service lives of the men and women who accepted their lot in the history of American civil and military command, and are now surrounded by Americans, frequently indifferent or ungenerous, rather than Iraqis who were also frequently indifferent or ungenerous.

Of course, Dr. James Peake earlier this year proposed outsourcing the administration of new Post-9/11 G.I Bill benefits, and the beneficiary of this would likely be California-based QTC Management, a private corporation that provides compensation and pension examinations for the VA. The current chairman of QTC is former VA secretary Anthony Principi and the good Dr. Peake was a senior exec there before taking the oath as Secretary of the Department of Veterans Affairs. (h/t Bruce Coulter.)

Something else to read is Bill Moyers' piece from last Memorial Day.

"Honoring our Veterans" is rhetoric that any decent person in electoral politics should deep six and replace with "Paying our Soldiers, during and after", or Lincoln's original message, "To care for him who shall have borne the battle, and for his widow, and his orphan”.

November 10, 2008

Noted

via Susan Crawford's blog (chock full of ICANN and FCC nuts), An Interview with Sarah Palin.

Fafblog has competition.

Table manners

The conversation at my table turned to mileage and manufacturing policy, and the tools for change ranged from subsidies for manufacturers to ... subsidies for manufacturers. Finally I asked "who voted for a Democrat yesterday?" The guy who claims he's the City of Portland (Oregon) makes a point of saying he's a contrarian (whateverthehellthatmeans) so he voted for McCain (he is a domainer, typo squatting pay-per-click slorg, so who cares?), but the rest of the table say "Obama" like tuned wineglasses struck in turn with a fork. I mention GM's paper is worthless, as is Chrysler's, and switching their product (that's the UAW's product also) from several less-then-CAFE units to several something like 2 x CAFE hybrids, via a quick trip through a nationalization bath (the Swedish Solution for broken banks, applied to manufacturers), is a choice. There's a moment's pause, then all these Democrats go back to how much tax incentive will get how much CAFEness in how many years.

The Republican smiled at me, and I smiled back. At least I wasn't sitting next to the lawyer for the domainers who was a personal friend of Norm Coleman that night. That had been the previous night.

ICANN Cairo Day 6 :: A view from Youtube

In this footage I'm sitting next to the camera, and the footage begins with Paul Strahura of Enom handing the mike to Dirk Krischenowski who makes the point that its not just .berlin that is at risk due to the time its taking ICANN to accept community-sponsored and city-sponsored applications, but also ICANN which is at risk. Next after Dirk are former ICANN Board member Nii Quanor who will clear up a misconception about the proposal for a .africa, followed by Young Eum who will comment on the oddity of treating Australia and New Zealand as "Asia" (to the general exclusion of non-Anglophones and the specific preference of Sydney over Seoul for the next "Asia" ICANN meeting), and the overwhelming US/European origins of the ICANN staff. Her message will result in what really is a surprising outburst the following day by Paul Twomey, the president of ICANN (and an Ausie).

One of the interesting bits of ICANN-ology is the fact that there is a queue behind Dirk. Staff has scattered mics all over the hall to make the queue "go away", but we still queue up. Later I'll speak from the farthest corner of the hall, where a mic finds me, on the problem of regions and assumptions, and suggest that . we need more poor people where it matters.

ICANN Cairo Days 1-7 :: A View via Youtube

The video begins with day 1 at the first of two back-to-back days for the GNSO Council, the policy making body for generic (as opposed to "country code") top-level domains. The sequence begins with me asking Kurt (ICANN staff) a question that seems to be about policy but is actually about process -- how does the Council re-assert a policy reversed by Staff? See link.

Visible in the first segment are Tim Ruiz, VP of Policy for GoDaddy (pink shirt on my right, largest registrar by market share and rep from the Registrar Constituency), across the table are Paul Strahura of Enom (2nd largest registrar by share, an observer), Adrian Kinders (AusReg, also an RC rep). Responding initially are Avri Doria, nomcom rep to the Council and chair, followed by Kurt's (Staff) response. Also in the frame are Mike Palage, observer and former rep, Glenn de Saint Gery (Staff), and several Registry Constituency reps, the closest being Jordi Ipa (.cat), next to Avri is co-chair Chuck Gomes (Verisign and a rep) and across the table, Thomas Roessler (W3C), the incoming technical liaison to the ICANN Board. There are several ICANN Board members "in chairs" or at the table between the GNSO Council reps and the observers.

Next is Werner Staub asking about the false dichotomy between "open" and "community" models later the same session (which we call "the GNSO showing of the Kurt Show", Kurt repeats this several times during the week). Next to Werner and not very visible are most of the Registry Constituency reps and observers, with the exception of Chuck, who's next to Avri as co-chairs.

The next segments are for tone -- our booth, where we did a surprising amount of business, I'd no idea our reputation was so high, our workshop ("GAC stuff" means Bertrand was writing something for the Governmental Advisory Committee, which he co-chairs), which got very high marks from the Intellectual Property constituency and others, and one of the quieter moments of Kash Mahdavi's party for .tel (seriously, a half dozen shawms qualify as an acoustic WMD, a belly dancer is not inherently dangerous) out at Giza, and footage from the trip organized by Skenzo -- so a bus load of ICANN accredited registrars and domainers (typo-squatting and expired domains pay-per-click and similar monitization schemes type people).

November 07, 2008

We have the DCCC, but ...

OK, so Rahm is history, moving off to take Josh Lyman's job (yes, that character was modeled on Rahm, so life imitates art which imitates life, or recursion actually can be taught to policy wonks who couldn't code their way out of a wet paper bag), but the next DTRIP is more than likely to be very much like the last DTRIP which was very much like the DTRIP before it which ... yet another example of recursive descent.

So ... a Progressive Congressional Campaign Committee. The PCCC. The PC Campaign Committee for those with a sense of humor.

Anyway, the OH-15 will have a primary in 18 months. There's no sense in letting a trending blue district (and after the 2010 census and redistricting, a wicked blue district -- 250,000 residents of the City of Columbus), remain represented by the mortgage bank lobbyist who's campaign just beat the best-funded worst-executed campaign I've ever seen the inside of (one of the top three DCCC targeted races in this cycle), or by some lame Rahm-the-Younger parachutist.

And there are others. Blue Dogs that need a primary challenge to help them (a) make more money in the private sector as lobbyists, or (b) move glacially to the left or (c) follow Holly Joe into the Sinai.

We have our "FDR", now we have to force his administration to deliver like FDR's. The sitting-on-laurels is for the O-bots who just voted top-of-ticket, who wouldn't notice policy, progressive or regressive, if it bit them.

ICANN Cairo Day 7 :: Board Meeting

I was disappointed to learn that ICANN staff had recommended Sydney over Seoul for the next Asia meeting. "Asia" in ICANN-esse means Anglophones in Austrailia and New Zealand and the occasional exception elsewhere in Asia.

worldBlacksmall.png

The current board let the staff error go -- Seoul's cost was $300,000 more than Sydney's, but the issue is much more than what are, to be honest, peanut (note the singular) in ICANN's budget, but "corrected" by deciding to hold the next meeting in Seoul, bumping Europe (and our bid for Barcelona) off the 2009 schedule.

The previous day when the Board was taking public comment on regional diversity there was no shortage of comment to the effect that a pile of Aussies and Kiwis did not add up to a bit of Asian representation in a predominantly Anglo-American organization. I rose to speak to the regions not being quite it either, and that OEDC vs non-OEDC was more likely to bring us views we don't already know (as if more reps from the rich bits of North America and Europe were likely to increase human knowledge about network needs), see map above, etc.

It was well received. The same point in the Registrar's Constituency, where I even argued that there is more money to be made if we can get a smarter about diverse material conditions Board and Staff and Councils seemed to fall rather flat.

November 06, 2008

ICANN Cairo Day 6 :: I attend a meeting of the Arab League

The entire meeting was in Arabic, except for ICANN keywords, which actually made it easy to follow. Being I suppose one of the available iso3166 wonks, I spent part of the meeting chatting with my seatmates on nuances relevant to ICANN and the Arab League.

It was interesting watching the Government Advisory Committee (GAC), At Large (ALAC) and Country Code (CCNSO) and the few "generic" people thrash out why, and how, to improve their collective advocacy, their lobbying, and all in Arabic. I was a fly on the wall, doing "traffic analysis" on English keywords, as revolution against Euro-American-centricism was being plotted, for a second time.

More on "the Pink Bits" and Euro-American-centricism tomorrow, when the Board trys to dig its way out of having been recommended to schedule the Asia meeting in an English speaking country (again).

November 05, 2008

ICANN Cairo Day 5 :: For my Sins

In the mid-afternoon we held our workshop -- a first for us -- on the ICANN meeting schedule, in a room ICANN provided, with ICANN scribes and ICANN translators and ICANN audio and text feeds to to the network-attached world. The session before ours was Internet Governance, the session after ours was ICANN Strategic Planning, so we were in the warm-to-hot part of the stove-top.

While the feeds were set up I told a story -- eleven years ago I had a few ideas while participating in Working Group C -- the working group (or zoo) tasked to consider, and perhaps answer, the questions of how many new gTLDs to be introduced in 2000/2001, and what kinds. Anyway, I wrote them down and posted it and from that paper came the model of sponsored gTLDs, such as .aero, .coop and .museum, and for my punishment Louis Touton had me edit the XML in the registry contract "live" during the Montevideo ICANN meeting. A few years later the model of a linguistic and cultural gTLD, which was also in that paper, was turned into an application for .cat, and as punishment Amadeu Abril y Abril asked me at the Rome ICANN meeting to be the CTO for the application for .cat. Finally, this year another idea in the paper, that "rights of others" means more than just trademark, and rights senior to trademark, came to life and was adopted by the Intellectual Property practitioners who also lobby ICANN, and as punishment I was the convener of today's workshop. The lesson here isn't that I'm wicked clever or to stupid to avoid oncoming cars (a Cairo traffic and pedestrian metaphore), but that the temporal offset from articulation to execution is some non-trivial number of years.

Of course, those ideas were all in the Working Group C paper for a top-level domain for Indians, one we policy and operate, a "g" under ICANN Consensus Guidelines, rather than a "c", which I'd asked Jon Postel for, and which the rush of events -- the mad scramble for seats, the better seats, at the table of the "new entity" froze out all other projects and resulted in what we call ICANN, or on bad days, "ICANN'T".

The workshop was a success. The Intellectual Property Constituency will kill some applicants, but they've chosen not to bloody our collective swim suits, and we sold our ideas to the subset of the swarm of applicants who aren't in it for the chum.

A day well spent. I think the real punishment was having to listen to a hammy voice-over at the light-show out at the pyramids culminating a grade-Z sci-fi script in a thunderous voice "Man fears Time but Time fears the Pyramids!!!"

Fortunately I got to chat with someone partial to the idea that people with handsets but not laptops will produce, not simply consume translated-for-size, content for other people with handsets but not laptops.

A Dark Time

The clerk at the bookstore almost begged that I vote for Senator Obama. I explained that he wasn't my candidate. She knew about Senator Clinton. I explained that she wasn't my candidate. She knew about Senator Edwards. A young, very well educated Egyptian woman, and very well informed, and very concerned about the world affected by the United States.

In the evening I went to a marketing event for the .tel registry, an extravaganza out at Giza. My neighbor was a friend of Norm Coleman, so we couldn't hope for the same outcomes. I spent some time sipping .tel's champagne and looking out across the way to the pyramids. Like my worries, a pack of wild dogs flowed across the shadows between our noisy, gay, nonsense and the silent works of men and women long past.

I went to bed with only Vermont announced. I woke up to see Senators Obama and Biden and their wives and families on Al Jazeera, and drew the obvious, and reassuring conclusion. Not another Karl Rove farce. I saw a man I voted for, Jesse Jackson, in tears, and I too cried.

November 04, 2008

ICANN Cairo Day 4 :: My Two Plus Hats

I start the day in the Registry Constituency meeting and end it in the Registrar Constituency meeting. The new gtlds handbook is almost the only issue in either room. The existing registries look at the proposed contract with horror -- ICANN proposes that it can modify the contract with the new gtld registries at any time -- that sets a precedent and eventually it may bite the existing registries also. The existing registrars look at the new gtld application fees with absurd interest -- not because they are sufficient concerned about the viability of registry start-ups to find a means to solve a problem that has existed since .museum, .aero, and .coop were launched in the 2001 round, but because many are planning to submit applications to operate registries.

Can registries own registrars? We started with a single, unified registry-registrar model -- it was Network Solutions, split into the Verisign Global Registry and Network Solutions Registrar units, so we have a "no" rule. But can registrars own registries? Can a registry own a registrar if the registrar does not do registrations for that registry, but for others?

Finally, while we don't talk much (if at all) about those who don't have any meaningful access to the namespace (and I'm so amused by staff's concern about "protecting the registrants", and making the start-up cost for community-based registries identical with the start-up cost for speculative registries, Indians are protected wicked good by not allowing them to have any namespace), we're wasting time talking about what if the Trumps want a vanity tld. A .trump. or a .trademark. A lot of registrars are stirring up the trademark holders with the message "You must apply for .foobar, and we can help you.", where "foobar" is just about any corporate name or mark. Dot IBM. Dot Kleenex. Dot Junk. But Dot Money.

Payday lenders go mobile

An issue I'd hoped the candidate in the OH-15th would work, even before the market crashed a month ago, was payday lending. The republican candidate being a mortgage lending lobbyist with a record of opposition to regulation and a payday lending issue being on the ballot made this appear rather obvious. At least to us, not that particular campaign, which may win, or lose, the lottery today, on the coattails of the national campaign, which prior to the market crash, was several points down in Ohio, and in the OH-15.

Here's an absolute gem from the W3C's mobile web for development mailing list: in Finland (home of Nokia) mobile phones are being used to offer "loans" at an annual interest rate of 298%.

Under the deregulate-is-always-good umbrella, it never rains.

November 03, 2008

ICANN Cairo Day 3 :: The State Reception

Mercifully, the Egyptian Government was too busy to fill the evening with a speaker, and we few, we happy few, we band of Smothers Brothers, could spend the evening at the Barron's Hindu Palace talking with each other about petty nonsense.

ICANN Cairo Day 3 :: Evaluating Community Based Applications

The ICANN RFP (now "Guidebook") currently has the following comparative evaluation criteria. This is wicked important for community applications which anticipate predatory, or bogus competing "community" application(s). So without further ado:

OK. Some further ado. The choice of the string being the name of, or abbreviation of, a "community institution" is slightly deranged. The names of community institutions are rarely the names of the community.

Ok. Ok. NOTE BENE: A score of 11 out of 12 is required to meet the minimum threshold. One point off is a pass. Two or more points off is a fail.

Criteria & Score


Criteria321
Nexus between Proposed String and Community String is name or well- known abbreviation of community institution. String is relevant to applicant’s area of interest but also has other well-known associations. No connection.
Dedicated Registration Policies Registration eligibility is strictly limited to members of the pre- established community identified in the application. Registration policies also include name selection and use requirements consistent with the articulated scope and community-based nature of the TLD. Proposed policies include specific enforcement measures including investigation practices, penalties, takedown procedures and appeal mechanisms. Registration eligibility is predominantly available to members of the pre- established community identified in the application, and also permits people or groups informally associated with the community to register. Policies include some elements of the above but one or more elements are missing. No dedicated registration policies.
Community Establishment Clearly identified, organized and pre- established community of considerable size and longevity. The community addressed fulfills some but not all the requirements for a score of 3. No community addressed.
Community Endorsement Endorsement by a recognized institution or by member organizations. Endorsement by some groups with apparent relevance, but also some opposition by groups with apparent relevance. Assorted endorsements from individuals or groups of unknown relevance – or – no endorsement by any community.

The substitution of "community institution" for "the community" in the string, or its abbreviation, forces any community with multiple "community institutions", say NAACP and SCLS, to pick one (or the concatenations of both, a comic ".naacpsclc"). As I'll be saying throughout comments on the RFP the problem is that the system is not designed to produce reasonable outcomes. Clearly forcing communities to stuff the names, or abbreviations of pre-net institutions, into the dns, and use those names or abbreviations for a purpose they were not intended, is unreasonable, as is forcing communities with multiple institutions to jam multiple names or abbreviations into the string.

So, my action item is, in geek speek, s/institution//.

November 02, 2008

Don't buy HP

I've now gone through two HP laptops and have had nothing but a nightmare experience. The first, I thought was just lemon. Now, however, I'm convinced. Not only is their product crap, but their customer service and repair department is a mess.

I'm done. I'm replacing my $2000 laptop with a Mac.

ICANN Cairo Day 2 :: Democrats Abroad

41.2.jpeg

One of my friends from Cambodia just sent me this from far far away ... across the room where the GNSO Council is meeting. Enjoy.

ICANN Cairo Day 2 :: Two communities, one speculator

Draft Applicant Guidebook, Module 4 String Contention Procedures, has a process for determining the outcome where two or more community-based applications, an one or more speculative (or "commercial" or "open", which ever adjective suits one's tastes) application for some string (or set of similar strings) exists.

Suppose that there are four applications for ".cherokee": one by the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma (CNO), one by the United Kitowah Band (UKB), one by the Eastern Cherokee Nation (ECN), and of course, one by Chrysler LLC, (JEEP).

Suppose that at least one of the three community-based applications elect for comparative evaluation. This sends all of the applications in the contention set to comparative evaluation. Because the Chrysler LLC application is not community-based, it can not win the comparative evaluation. However, if at least two of the CNO, UKB and ECN applications meet the comparative evaluation's minimum threshold, then there is no clear winner of the technical evaluation.

The staff proposed "next step" at this point is for all of the applications in the original contention set to bid for .cherokee. Obviously Chrysler LLC wins at this point and the ICANN process awards .cherokee in the unique DNS global root in perpetuity (or as long as grass grows, rivers flow, and car manufacturing, or alternatively, brand management is profitable, to Chrysler LLC.

So, if two or more community-based applications exist for a string, or two "similar" strings, then the string will go to any non-community-based application for the same, or similar string, if it has better access to bidding capital.

Similarly, suppose one of the set of applications from the {CNO, UKB, ECN} does not meet the minimum threshold, and Chrysler LLC, for some reason, withdraws its bid. Again, the contention set goes to auction, and the the ICANN process awards .cherokee in the unique DNS global root in perpetuity, to the applicant with the best access to bidding capital, which could have been the application which did not meet the minimum threshold.

So, if if two or more community-based applications exist for a string, or two "similar" strings, then the string will go to the community-based application for the same, or similar string, that has better access to bidding capital.

Restated, any name of any community can be captured by submitting, or causing to be submitted, a pro-forma "community-based" application which meets the "minimum threshold", and optionally, if the goal is a "open" registry, a separate non-community-based application, with better access to bidding capital than the actual community submitting a community-based application.

November 01, 2008

ICANN Cairo Day 1 :: Notice to Indians, Bloggers, ...

Today is GNSO Council, full-day-o-work. This issue is (insert favorite set of indigenous polities) vs car company, or bloggers vs exploiters of blogs, and here is where we are at the moment.



1.2.2 Two Application Types: Open or Community-Based


All applicants are required to designate each application for a new gTLD as open or community-based.

1.2.2.1 Definitions


For purposes of this RFP, an open gTLD is one that can be used for any purpose consistent with the requirements of the application and evaluation criteria, and with the registry agreement. An open gTLD may or may not have a formal relationship with an exclusive registrant or user population. It may or may not employ eligibility or use restrictions.

For purposes of this RFP, a community-based gTLD is a gTLD that is operated for the benefit of a defined community consisting of a restricted population. An applicant designating its application as community-based will be asked to substantiate its status as representative of the community it names in the application, and additional information may be requested in the event of a comparative evaluation (refer to Section 4.2 of Module 4).

An applicant for a community-based gTLD is expected to:

  1. Demonstrate an ongoing relationship with a defined community that consists of a restricted population.
  2. Have applied for a gTLD string strongly and specifically related to the community named in the application.
  3. Have proposed dedicated registration and use policies for registrants in its proposed gTLD.
  4. Have its application endorsed in writing by an established institution representing the community it has named.

Applicants should understand how their designation as open or community-based will affect application processing at particular stages, as described in the following paragraphs.

Objection/Dispute Resolution – All applicants should understand that an objection may be filed against any application on community opposition grounds, even if the applicant has not designated itself as community-based or declared the TLD to be aimed at a particular community.

Refer to Module 3, Dispute Resolution Procedures.

String Contention – Any applicant that has been identified as part of a contention set (refer to Module 4.1) may be obliged to participate in either a comparative evaluation or another efficient mechanism for contention resolution if the application reaches the string contention stage and the applicant elects to proceed.

A comparative evaluation will take place if a community-based applicant in a contention set has elected
comparative evaluation.

Another efficient mechanism for contention resolution will result in other cases. If a comparative evaluation occurs but does not produce a clear winner, the efficient mechanism will then result.
Refer to Module 4, String Contention Procedures, for detailed discussions of contention resolution procedures.

Contract Execution and Post-Delegation – A community-based gTLD applicant will be subject to certain post-delegation contractual obligations to operate the gTLD in a manner consistent with the restrictions associated with its community-based designation, once it begins operating the gTLD. ICANN must approve material changes to the community-based nature of the gTLD and any associated
contract changes.

1.2.2.3 Changes to Application Designation

An applicant may not change its designation as open or community-based once it has submitted a gTLD application for processing.

Source: Pages 12 and 13 of Module 1 Introduction to the gTLD Application Process.



I've already asked my question: "How did we get from community-based being "disposative" where there are two or more applications for the same string, say ".cherokee" or ".blog", to where it is "a factor" (of limited value)?" The answer is Kurt and I will confer (on the policy), and the GNSO Council will have a chance on Wednesday to consider how its policy ("determinative") has been transformed (to "a factor"), and what the Council has to do to re-instruct Staff. To be continued.

At the Cairo Museum

A friend from Quebec and I spent a pleasant mid-day at the museum. We started in the Old Kingdom and eventually made it to the Roman period. I found an alcove of pre-dynastic ceramics, where seriation was first developed.
P1000326.jpg

My friend was kind enough to take a few pictures for Jonah. Afterwards we had lunch on the Nile, and then went to the venue hotel.

we're using {mt v4.x || wp v2.x || drupal v6.x}, {mysql v 5.x || postgresql v8.x}, perl v5.8.8, php v5.2.5, python2.5.2 and apache v2.x, all running on freebsd-releng_7, on one of four ixsystems, housed in the usawebhost colo space in portland maine. everything is minded by ebw. all work by mb williams and eric brunner-williams are © wampum.