« Bush Administration backs down, nominates Humetewa | Main | Transitions :: Floyd Red Crow Westerman »

Indians and Non-Indians

When we look for blogs that go to the root causes, to Rehnquist's Oliphant v. Suquamish for the jurisdictional mechanism that protects perpetrators of violence against women, or Cobell v. Clinton's Babbit, then v. Bush's Norton, and now v. Bush's Kempthorne, for the principle of trust that protects perpetrators of theft of individual property, we come up thin to empty.

So we see the outpouring of cash that comes from the PayPal clickstreams of blogs that fund raise for the womens shelter on the Standing Rock Rez as kin to Missionary Barrels. Putting on our American hats we become even less charitable. Private charity, preferably channeled through Christian cults, not public policy, is the dogma of Republicans.

Make no mistake, sixty-k dollars plus a ten-k hat for any detached residential unit, would be nice, even if a handout from White Liberals, but it's no substitute for fixing what's broken anymore than holding bake sales is an effective response to defunding public education.

Yes, the following liberal bloggers posted on Markos Moulitsas Zúniga's community scoop or on their own blogs:

nbier, flautist, sarac, njgoldfinch, Devilstower, Christy Hardin-Smith, mole333, DB, William Neuheisel, and no doubt others

But they don't write about Indian issues, about what's broken and what can be fixed. They've adopted a poster child, and that's all they've screwed themselves up to the sticking point to do. To steal a quote from Noel Pearson, responding to an event that is also making the rounds in the liberal blogs, also in isolation:

In my view, unless we tackle grog and welfare, the problems of this 10-year-old child at Aurukun ultimately will have no solution.

Noel has long argued passive welfare is to blame for a complete breakdown in social norms in Indigenous communities, in Cape York and elsewhere in Australia. His point is that responding to one report of child abuse because the abuse was pack rape, and ignoring the thousands of open or unfiled reports of child abuse because the abuse isn't sexual, just malnutrition or general care -- 80 reported and 30 substantiated per month in Cape York. just isn't reality based.

And yes, on the order of eight hundred people clicked through the donations links for a total of $50,000. So here's the link to contribute to the "netroots", or DailyKos+FireDogLake+... effort to buy a single bandaid.

What you won't get from DK/FDL/... is Abramoff as a complex crook who supports tribal soverignty reckoned in billions of dollars, or the full measure of inter-locked corruption at Interior and Justice, also to the tune of billions of dollars, or the embedding of sexual assault white privilege in Federal Indian Law, not as a crime of war, as the International Criminal Tribunal in the Hague determined systematic rapes in 1996 in Kosovo, but as the necessary consequence of eroding tribal criminal jurisdiction, re-affirmed every October by the Supreme Court of the United States.

And so on. These are issues, stories, complex and human interest, that these liberal bloggers don't write or link to, and haven't for as long as they've each been around as on-line venues of political writings. Its why we didn't hold the Koufax Awards this year -- we're tired of people who only read Wampum to see their names, and if their names come first, or close enough to be cool, before going back to their no-Indians-or-Dogs avocations.

We're happy to see the Feminist Law Profs Blog do a post -- Unprosecuted Abuse of Native American Women, but its Zero Hour was April this year, when the Amnesty report got earned media. We hope they go the distance, it would be good to have another progressive legal group of co-authors go the distance too.

We're now offering civicrm in drupal, joomla!, and standalone configurations, as well as MediaWiki, JSPWiki and Xwiki, as well as the blog standards: MovableType and WordPress. If you have an electoral candidate or issue campaign you'd like to have done by non-nonsense pros who've flesh in the game, or delight in web 2.0 tech, drop Eric a line.
-->

Comments

EBW - I think you missed this post:
http://feministlawprofs.law.sc.edu/?p=1739
Granted it primarily only links to another blog, but it does reference the Amnesty report, we didn't ignore it.

I know this is going to sound defensive but I get really tired of being told what I should be doing and what I should be blogging. Anytime YOU write and post something related to feminism, e-mail me a link and I'd certainly consider trying to send FLP readers your way. Same goes for things you read other places. That's a much more productive strategy (at least with me) than trying to induce feelings of guilt or shame about blogging priorities.

double_curve.gif

I'm not sure its productive to try to make us feel guilty for not pontificating on root causes of these issues. The Amnesty report (which I linked to) did that better than I could have. I try not to speak for these women. Instead, I do what I can to raise awareness and funds to support safe houses and other programs that allow abused women to escape and survive, and ultimately find their own voice as many of them have done. I've met some of them personally, like Jackie Brown Otter, and Georgia Little Shield, and have found them to be quite effective speaking for themselves.

Who will stand up and speak out if Pretty Bird Woman House closes and their best potential leaders and advocates are murdered or beaten into silence? Certainly things will not be solved simply by throwing money (I'm the last person to believe that), and there are policy issues at play, but that was a bit beyond the scope of my post. There was a pressing need, and an opportune moment to raise awareness and involve a larger community, and so I tried to do my part.

I definitely want to see stronger efforts to grow opportunity and access in Native communities, but I have personal connections to Pretty Bird Woman House, so that is where I feel I can be most effective.

double_curve.gif

Post a comment

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://wampum.wabanaki.net/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/3729

we're using {mt v4.x || wp v2.x || drupal v6.x}, {mysql v 5.x || postgresql v8.x}, perl v5.8.8, php v5.2.5, python2.5.2 and apache v2.x, all running on freebsd-releng_7, on one of four ixsystems, housed in the usawebhost colo space in portland maine. everything is minded by ebw. all work by mb williams and eric brunner-williams are © wampum.