« The 2005 Koufax Awards Finalists: Most Humorous Post | Main | The 2005 Koufax Awards Finalists: Best New Blog »

The 2005 Koufax Awards Finalists: Best Blog Commenter

Chris Clarke (Berube, Rox Populi)

The Fat Lady Sings (DKos - The Relative Death of a Child)

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

LowerManhattanite (Steve Gilliard)

Paul Lukasiak (Washington Note, TPM Cafe)

MERKIN PATRIOT (Eschaton)

Meteor Blades (Daily Kos, Booman Tribune)

Norbizness (Pandagon, Sadly, No!, generally everywhere in Blogtopia)

NTodd (Atrios)

Teh L4m3 (Sadly, No!, Eschaton)

Wu Ming (My Left Wing)

We're now offering civicrm in drupal, joomla!, and standalone configurations, as well as MediaWiki, JSPWiki and Xwiki, as well as the blog standards: MovableType and WordPress. If you have an electoral candidate or issue campaign you'd like to have done by non-nonsense pros who've flesh in the game, or delight in web 2.0 tech, drop Eric a line.
-->

Comments

norb! norb FOR NO REASON AT ALL!

(norb-IZNESS, that is)

double_curve.gif

Wu Ming, at My Left Wing

Hey, that rhymes.

ALL THE MORE REASON!

double_curve.gif

wu ming

double_curve.gif

wu ming, always brilliant

double_curve.gif

Wu Ming (My Left Wing)

double_curve.gif

wu ming

double_curve.gif

Wu Ming

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

me!

(i also comment at dailykos FWIW, but i'm not sure if this is blogcentric or bloggercentric)

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

wu ming

double_curve.gif

Wu Ming (My Left Wing) always inciteful commentary.

double_curve.gif

wu ming the wise, penetrating and humane.

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings

double_curve.gif

I'd like to cast a vote for myself, please:

The Fat Lady Sings

Thank you - and good luck to everyone here!

double_curve.gif

Teh L4m3 (Sadly, No!, Eschaton)

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

wu ming at My Left Wing is the king for he comments with zing with the wit of Chandler Bing and makes the Awesome Bell ring with a very loud DING!

I'd apologize for that, but I'm not sorry in the least.

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak--still the best expert on Bush's National Guard service (or lack of service?)

double_curve.gif

Norbizness!

double_curve.gif

wu_ming

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 - DailyKos

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades just edges out Georgia10.

double_curve.gif

teh l4m3 at 3Bulls!

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke.

double_curve.gif

wu ming, because capitalizing is over rated.

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

MERKIN PATRIOT

Get a brain, morans!

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

wu ming!

double_curve.gif

georgia10

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

I cast my vote to Norbizness for this most dubious of honors.

double_curve.gif

Teh l4m3 at 3Bulls!

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades!

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades is simply the best.

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blade......by a razors edge!

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Norbizness.

double_curve.gif

norbizness

double_curve.gif

NTodd

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

teh l4m3

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades is simply the best.

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Lowermanhattanite as Steve Gilliard's News Blog :)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

NTodd. Absolutely.

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

chris clarke

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Thats another fine mess needs to take the cake !!!!!!!!!

double_curve.gif

Lower Manhattanite.

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Sorry to be a bother - but could you please add this dKos link? I am getting emails asking just what specific commentary I'm nominated for. This will give people an example of my work there. Thanks again!

On The Relative Death of a Child

double_curve.gif

NTodd, where ever he comments

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades.

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings for sure

double_curve.gif

Norbiz.

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke, Creek Running North

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke.

double_curve.gif

teh l4m3

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite (Steve Gilliard)

double_curve.gif

Tough choice between Meteor Blades and Georgia10, but gotta go with Georgia10 -- it all started with her Ohio Vote "white paper"

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

NTodd

Only b/c he pays.

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke!

double_curve.gif

NTodd

Only b/c he pays.

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Wu ming, My Left Wing

double_curve.gif

NTodd, of course!

double_curve.gif

NTodd, and his pants.

double_curve.gif

Wu Ming @ Maryscott O'Connor's "My Left Wing" btw/ said blog should win Best Blog Name.

double_curve.gif

Steve Gilliard

double_curve.gif

Wu Ming @ Maryscott O'Connor's "My Left Wing" btw/ said blog should win Best Blog Name.

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

wu ming

double_curve.gif

Wu Ming, who I see at Daily Kos also where he is fab.

double_curve.gif

Teh L4m3 (Sadly, No!, Eschaton)

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke.

double_curve.gif

Norbizness, especially for his comments on Flickr

double_curve.gif

Teh L4m3 (Sadly, No!, Eschaton)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades at Daily Kos.

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

NTodd

double_curve.gif

Wu ming @ My Left Wing

double_curve.gif

Love Merkin, but NTodd is numero uno, no question.

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

Meteor, with Blades!

double_curve.gif

MERKIN PATRIOT (Eschaton)

double_curve.gif

I love both Georgia10 and Meteor Blades' writing...G10 by a nose.

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

NTodd

double_curve.gif

teh l4me, for bloggy goodness.

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

wu ming, My Left Wing

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite

double_curve.gif

teh l4m3

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Teh L4m3(not to be confused with L3h T4m3)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades.

double_curve.gif

Teh L4m3, esq.

double_curve.gif

lower manhattanite at the news blog

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite (Steve Gilliard)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Georgia10--she's only 23, and more worthy than 10,000 Ben Domenechs.

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

lower manhattanite

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Norbiz 'cuz I feel guilty about not voting for him for humor.

double_curve.gif

wu ming! I be lovin his comments. I learn something new from him. and thats saying alot, because bascially I know everything :)

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

LEFT WING

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)!

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak (Washington Note, TPM Cafe)

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

Georgia10.

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak (Washington Note, TPMCafe)

double_curve.gif

norbizness - making posts better thru mad skillz.

double_curve.gif

NTodd

double_curve.gif

the fat lady sings (daily kos)

double_curve.gif

meteor blades

double_curve.gif


teh l4m3 (Sadly, No!, Eschaton)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades (but everyone on this list rocks)

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke, for making breakfast liquids come out of my nose on more than one occassion.

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

Marginally brighter than the other stars

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Luaptifer (ePluribus Media)

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (dailykos), she gives me hope for our future!

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Wu Ming! He's f'in brilliant!

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak (Washington Note, TPM Cafe)

double_curve.gif

teh l4m3 1n a 14nd51id3

double_curve.gif

georgia10

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

NTodd

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

wow! can I take myself out of the running? I'm incredibly flattered to have been nominated, but when I look at the competition, I have to say I'm well out of my league.

(I'm voting for Georgia10 myself.... although the choice is REALLY tough!)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Georgia10-dailykos

double_curve.gif

NTodd

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke is always worth reading, on any number of topics.

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings (DKos - The Relative Death of a Child)

double_curve.gif

Thank you, Mary Beth - thank you so very much for fixing that link. I hope you're feeling better today.

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

No! Not a choice between Georgia10 and Meteor Blades!

I have to go with Georgia10 because Meteor Blades has gotten some rec in the past. Both, however, are faves.

double_curve.gif

Lower Manhattanite

double_curve.gif

MERKIN PATRIOT. A true genius. Sheer brilliant lunacy.

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

NTodd

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke.

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 earns my vote.

double_curve.gif

Merkin Patriot (Eschaton)

(although I'm being forced to keep trying to post this -- I promise I'm not being malicious -- just trying to get through all this voting)

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak is much too modest. Not that the others aren't terrific, too, but Lukasiak Skywalker gets my nod.

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Georgia10.

double_curve.gif

although i have much love for ntodd's endurance and stamina when it comes to quality comments, and i utterly respect the serious and significant contributions of such all-stars as G10 and CC, i just can't help but feel that the combination of on-topicness, humor, wit, the ironic use of misspelling and wrong context, and an uncanny ability to mock the fundies while keeping the left in stitches makes MERKIN PATRIOT the clear choice.

MP: because without him, we'd have all killed ourselves a long time ago.

double_curve.gif

georgia10

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak - his work on the Texas Air National Guard and President Bush will become part of the historical record of this era.

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

MERKIN PATRIOT (Eschaton)

double_curve.gif

NTodd

double_curve.gif

teh l4m3!

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

wu ming at My Left Wing

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings (DKos - The Relative Death of a Child)

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings.

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak, for the AWOL truth telling and criticisms of the WP and other MSM.

double_curve.gif

georgia10

double_curve.gif

My vote goes to "The Fat Lady Sings"

double_curve.gif

wu ming

double_curve.gif

NTodd, because I've actually met him :)

double_curve.gif

Wu ming @ My Left Wing

double_curve.gif

NTodd (Atrios)

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings (DKos - The Relative Death of a Child)

double_curve.gif

Wu ming @ My Left Wing

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades.

double_curve.gif

Hands down - Meteor Blades.

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings for The Relative Death of a Child

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

I've gotta bring it on for the Fat Lady! She's consistantly a terrific commenter.

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings (DKos - The Relative Death of a Child)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

Teh L4m3

double_curve.gif

Lower Manhattenite. No contest.

double_curve.gif

Lukasiak. Bush is still AWOL.

double_curve.gif

wow, tough choice to make here - fat lady sings' story
makes for devastating reading, and of course meteor blades
is always pithy and puissant, but i must slavishly and
sheepishly take my place with the lockstep-lefty personality
cult of NTodd. it's the atriotic thing to do.

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

NTodd

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings (DKos - The Relative Death of a Child)

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

Tough race, but Georgia10 takes first with grace and style.

double_curve.gif

Norbizness.

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Ntodd

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades. Second, NTodd.

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite (Steve Gilliard)

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite (Steve Gilliard)

double_curve.gif

NTodd (Atrios)

double_curve.gif

MERKIN PAYTRIOT! BANK ON IT!

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak (Washington Note, TPM Cafe)

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak (Washington Note, TPM Cafe)

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings (DKos - The Relative Death of a Child)

double_curve.gif

Merkin Patriot cuz he is

double_curve.gif

Merkin Patriot

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak.

double_curve.gif

georgia10

double_curve.gif

MERKIN PATRIOT

double_curve.gif

I like Georgia10 at Kos.

double_curve.gif

meteor blades

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke, CRN

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite (Steve Gilliard)

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

norb, again.

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

As I don't see XristiM or ellroon here, my vote has to go to Ntodd.

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

ntoddntoddntodd

double_curve.gif

georgia10

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite.
Gilliard gets a lot of comments, but my mouse always comes to a complete and respectful stop when LowerManhattanite is in the house. He's both consistently brilliant and sui generis; like finding a gold coin in a cup of good coffee.

double_curve.gif

sorry everyone else, but best commentator:

Lower Mahattanitte (Steve's News Blog)

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite

far and away the best

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite. Definitely.

As one of my co-workers says: "EX-cellent...."

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite

double_curve.gif

Lower Manhattanite (Steve Gilliard)

double_curve.gif


Georgia 10 at DailyKos. Outstanding work over the past year.

double_curve.gif

georgia10

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades...however, I will say that Gilliard's individual blog entries on News Blog are some of the best the liberal blogosphere has to offer.

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak (Washington Note, TPM Cafe -- and Firedoglake!!!)

double_curve.gif

Lower Manhattanite is consistently excellent.

double_curve.gif

Georgia10 (Daily Kos)

double_curve.gif

Lower Manhattanite is the action, Jackson.
In one comment you are likely to get drama, humor, passion, and at least one reference that will send you to Wikipedia to go learn a little something.

double_curve.gif

Georgia10

double_curve.gif

Wu Ming, My Left Wing

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings (DKos - The Relative Death of a Child)

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite is the one.

double_curve.gif

Meteor Blades

double_curve.gif

Chris Clarke

double_curve.gif

meteor blades

double_curve.gif

Norbizness

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite (what driftglass said)

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite (Steve Gilliard)

double_curve.gif

LowerManhattanite (Steve Gilliard)

double_curve.gif

I vote for The Fat Lady Sings!

double_curve.gif

Paul Lukasiak

double_curve.gif

WaPo journalist applicant and clear frontrunner... MERKIN PATRIOT!

double_curve.gif

The Fat Lady Sings

double_curve.gif

Lower Manhattanite.

double_curve.gif

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://wampum.wabanaki.net/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/2182

we're using {mt v4.x || wp v2.x || drupal v6.x}, {mysql v 5.x || postgresql v8.x}, perl v5.8.8, php v5.2.5, python2.5.2 and apache v2.x, all running on freebsd-releng_7, on one of four ixsystems, housed in the usawebhost colo space in portland maine. everything is minded by ebw. all work by mb williams and eric brunner-williams are © wampum.